Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ...
by scott_karana on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @04:28PM
(#6129803)
The high seas? Do you mean international waters, such as those off the coast of Somalia?
I'm just trying to make a point about warlike actions without formal declarations, in any case.
Re:Manning not guilty of aiding the enemy, but convicted of ...
by mpyne on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @06:31PM
(#6130557)
The U.S. made a formal declaration (the 2001 AUMF).
But I don't even have qualms comparing international waters to Afghanistan, because you have to consider that if a given piece of land is completely ungoverned, does it belong to a specific nation at all?
If you say that the lands in Afghanistan from which AQ organized their terrorism was effectively governed by the Taliban and not a failed state, then it's even easier legally, as you have an actual causus belli for military action in response.
The answer to your first question can be illuminated a bit by considering a different question: Why do seagoing nations use Naval assets (instead of a coast guard auxiliary) to interdict and defeat pirates on the high seas?