This would also curb the behavior of the large institution. They shouldn't be able to dump all of their holdings of a stock like that at a high price if there aren't real buyers at that price. The institution should be forced to chase the price down to pick up enough buyers for the whole position. If they still can't move it all, then they're holding a worthless stock. Sucks for them, but investing is a gamble and sometimes you lose your investment. You should've invested in a more valuable company.
The theme I'm getting at is that I think that market makers definitely alter the dynamics of the market, as they claim to, but contrary to their claims they do it in a way that benefits themselves and other financial institutions to the detriment of non-financial-industry investors and the companies and other real-value instruments (bond originators, mortgage borrowers, etc) being traded.
There are some issues with HFT that I don't like, where different players are getting different access to information. Beyond that, I have trouble with the argument that parties that aren't me should have to engage in transactions that I like the shape of (or the other way around, should be prevented from engaging in transactions that I don't like. I'm using transaction here in the sense that both parties are acting freely...).
As far as financial markets, reliable prices are worth something (even though a reliable price is 'just information'). I agree that in heavily traded instruments, providing liquidity becomes a fairly abstract value, but if you are a large institution, having someone that will readily purchase enormous amounts of shares is a valuable service. For a lightly traded instrument, being able to sell it is also a valuable service.
I don't see enormous value in having lots of people spending lots of money chasing pennies, but I have trouble getting worked up about it. I suppose what it comes down to is that I am skeptical that rules designating who gets the tiny bit of slop available in financial transactions will be any more fair than the present system (where various HFTs are competing for the slop, often by essentially offering some of it to the parties in the transaction...).