News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Observations from a Tipless Restaurant by javert on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @11:29AM (#6127547)
Why? Do you think the US government mostly spends that money on good things? They mostly spend it on foreign wars and throwing it at a broken and disfunctional black hole of education, healthcare and social programs.

People actually working in restaurants have earned that money and can use it to better their lives. It's a moral crime to forcibly take the money from them.

Re:Observations from a Tipless Restaurant by patmcc on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @11:55AM (#6127799)
So all taxation is immoral then?

I'm Canadian, so I could have more correctly written "CRA" instead of "IRS" - and on balance, I do believe my government spends the money on good things. Certainly there are parts I disagree with, but that's why I, you know, vote and stuff.

More importantly, I think a server who grosses $50,000 and a QA analyst who grosses $50,000 should end up paying the same amount in income taxes. The server shouldn't get a pass just because lots of his/her income comes in the form of tips.

Re:Observations from a Tipless Restaurant by javert on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @12:45PM (#6128192)
I think taxation is legitimate when needed for protection of people's rights, which is the purpose of government. (I acknowledge that people differ in what they think rights are, but that's a different discussion.) I also think it's OK to tax to fund programs that shouldn't be funded in the long run, while you're in the process of phasing them out; I'm not for changing things drastically overnight.

That said, I think it's wrong to think that the government can invest money more wisely or efficiently than the people who have earned it can, and I think it's morally wrong to take money from people (like wait staff--note that doing this materially hurts their pursuit of their own goals and happiness) for government boondoggle.