News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by joakleaf on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @09:47AM (#6126876)
I agree that too many people are employed by the public sector. This number grew rapidly in the 1970s, but has continue to grow (although much less) steadily since. http://punditokraterne.dk/2012/06/22/offentligt-ansatte-1970...

Do you mean that the danish "model" is broken, because the public finances run with a deficit and/or because of unemployment? It is still not obvious for me what you mean by broken.

Since the number of people employed in the public sector hasn't increased by more than around 10% since the 1980s, and the unemployment rate is now actually relatively low (5.8%), one could argue that the model really does work. It hasn't crashed over a period of 30 years. Public spending was excessive during the 2000s, so the "model" does need some refinement, and will like continue to undergoing constant refinement as the economy fluctuates.

The unemployment rate is currently dropping, and it is lower than e.g. UK (5.8% vs. 7.7%) and certainly Southern Europe. Unemployment is a reoccurring problem in a historical sense, and a much bigger problem in most of the world than Denmark. People everywhere struggle to find jobs as a consequence of increased automation. Especially, uneducated people.

Denmark is running with a deficit at the moment, but there have been years with surplus too. Of course, that could be explained by the income generated from natural resources (oil+gas), just as the deficit could be explained by fluctuations in the world economy.

The deficit in 2013 is expected to be 1.2% of GDP which isn't bad compared to everywhere else. National debt compared to GDP is higher in many countries: http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/774/economics/list-of-nati...

Another point you mention is that it is hard to grow a company because of lack of ambition in Denmark. It is hard to grow a company in Denmark, but I personally consider high salaries as a bigger problem than lack of ambition.

On a positive side, because there is very good support for unemployed people, Danish employment laws are less restrictive than many countries, making it much easier for companies to hire and fire their employees. Flexibility is very good thing for a company that wishes to grow.

If you say automation is making it hard for people to find a job, what do you propose as an alternative to educating people (you mention a large part is overeducated)?

Lowering taxes for corporations was a ridiculous idea. It is higher almost everywhere else, and nobody could give a compelling argument for lowering it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tax_rates

Corporate tax is paid of the profit, before the profit is distributed to its shareholders. 3 percentage points lower tax of dividends, before income tax, will not change much for the shareholders of Danish corporations.

You also haven't pointed to a country with a model you feel is working better.

Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by ThomPete on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @10:18AM (#6127060)
I am not sure why you insist on answers based on your claim that Denmark is currently doing better than others. That was not the point.

The article portrays Denmark as having no issues what so ever and a financially sound political model for the future.

What is broken is a lucrative and ineffective welfare system and the size of the public sector as it is primarily based on the income of the private sector.

With the majority of taxes being paid through income tax and with the number of private sector jobs disappearing and not enough new companies becoming growth companies, with a demographic structure requiring more from less and with a job market that is structurally in trouble (hidden for now by redistribution) it is bound to be trouble.

Lowering the taxes for corporations was not meant as anything but following the competition, there is nothing wrong in that. It's neither a smart move or a stupid move, it's just what you do if you don't want to add to the amount of jobs disappearing.

There really isn't anything to do by the state for those who have trouble finding jobs. There isn't some boom waiting in any foreseeable future. It's structural these days baby.

I don't find any of the current models working, but I am also more pessimistic about automation than most people.

Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by mseebach on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @10:25AM (#6127093)
> Lowering taxes for corporations was a ridiculous idea. It is higher almost everywhere else, and nobody could give a compelling argument for lowering it.

That's clearly your opinion and you're entitled to it, but please don't state it as fact, that's just dishonest.

> Corporate tax is paid of the profit, before the profit is distributed to its shareholders. 3 percentage points lower tax of dividends, before income tax, will not change much for the shareholders of Danish corporations.

No, it's paid of the profit at the end of the year, no matter what you do with that profit, including investing it next year or putting it into a rainy-day fund.

> You also haven't pointed to a country with a model you feel is working better.

Who said he had to? Why is it a premise for debate that there is a perfect country somewhere else that's working better? But Sweden.

Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by joakleaf on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @10:43AM (#6127189)
It is true that you can save up the profit for next year (a rainy day as you say), but that doesn't create growth or benefit society. In a sense if you have a higher corporate tax there is a larger incentive to spend that money in the same year on new hires, equipment, or assets. So you could argue that a larger corporate tax create more growth... However, that's just speculation on my part.

That lower corporate taxes doesn't benefit society wasn't actually my viewpoint, but it has been addressed quite a lot in the media. I should have pointed to some references. My bad:

Here is one from 2010. http://www.b.dk/danmark/eksperter-lavere-selskabsskat-har-li...

Two professors (one from Copenhagen Business School) and one from University of Århus states that it will have little impact.

Or a survey from business (67% of business don't think it will have an effect):

http://www.advodan.dk/nyheder/2013/4/7-ud-af-10-virksomheder...

It has also been discussed in America:

http://business.time.com/2012/02/23/will-a-lower-corporate-t...

I actually asked earlier if he could show me an example of a country with a better model to better explain in what sense the Danish model is "broken". Isn't the Swedish "model" almost identical to the Danish "model"?

Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by mseebach on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @11:09AM (#6127372)
Lowering the corporate tax rate won't create growth or jobs on it's own, it will preempt loosing it to eg. Sweden. Denmark is loosing jobs at an astounding rate. Keeping jobs in Denmark is a hurdle to clear before creating jobs and growth can meaningfully be discussed.

The Swedish model is very similar to the Danish model, except they spent the good years implementing many of the reforms ThomPete and I have been advocating. It's not perfect, but they're doing better.

Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by joakleaf on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @11:20AM (#6127474)
Do you have references regarding the "Denmark is loosing jobs at an astounding rate" statement?

It doesn't seem in line with the fact that the unemployment rate has been dropping over the last couple of years, or that it is in fact lower than it was in the 1990s.

I know the unemployment statistics doesn't necessarily give the true numbers, but you can't just state something like that without references.

Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by mseebach on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @11:42AM (#6127680)
http://www.altinget.dk/artikel/danmark-oplever-det-stoerste-...

The reason unemployment numbers look decent is partly that the numbers hide a larger number of people on "not-ready-for-work" benefits and partly the fact that the baby boomers are retiring. Pensioners are not considered unemployed.

Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by joakleaf on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @12:19PM (#6127996)
I wouldn't call a drop of 16000 in 2012 "astounding". It is 0.5% of the entire workforce. 6000 of those 16000 were from the public sector, so it was really just 10000 workplaces lost in the private sector in 2012 (Jan-Nov).

If I look at the statistics at http://www.dst.dk/pukora/epub/Nyt/2013/NR350.pdf I see a drop of unemployed of 10000 since October 2012. I don't know if that number directly translates into 10000 new jobs of the kind that were lost in your article.

But I think it is hard to determine if the 16000 mentioned in the article is just normal fluctuation over a 11 months.

With that said, the 160000 jobs lost since 2008 is significant, but unemployment was at a record low at that time. From the graph (I linked to), it looks like most of those 160000 jobs were lost in 2008 and 2009.

Do you have any numbers that do not mask pensioner's and "not- ready-for-work" people? It is hard make any actual judgment in any direction, if all the statistics are deemed untrustworthy or politically biased.

Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by ThomPete on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @02:39PM (#6129076)
Of the entire workforce? You mean of the private workforce.
Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by joakleaf on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @06:05PM (#6130359)
No. The entire workforce was 2818000 people in 2012 according to Wikipedia (http://da.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arbejdsstyrke). So an additional 16000 unemployed people constitute approximately 0.5% of the workforce.

I don't think it makes sense to talk about a "private workforce" in this context, as the workforce consists of all people able to perform work.

Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by ThomPete on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @08:36AM (#6133196)
It does make sense given that it's the private workforce that pays for the rest.
Re:Pace of modern life: UK v Denmark by ThomPete on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @10:48AM (#6127219)
Why do you insist on setting up a strawman for me to answer?

I just don't get it.