His suggestion that in order to keep your git history pristine you should just email patches until you can get to a working state seems bizarre. git is a tool that works really well for collaborating on something until it works. In a small project, who gives a crap if you see a commit that fixes the previous commit once in a blue moon. Yes, on a large project like the Linux kernel that might get annoying, but for 99% of people it's irrelevant.
It's not about pushing broken code, it's about having a very complex code base and you just can't foresee how each change will behave before it has been tested by a lot of people on a lot of different machines.
A linux release is a pretty good point in time to get a quite well tested version and therefore it's a good base for your changes and to be able to test how your changes - only your changes - behave.
To me, it doesn't sound meaningfully different from walking over to a coworker and arguing over the code or its results for a while. The "emailing patches" thing seems more like a slow-by-necessity feedback loop due to the fact that Linux contributors are across the world and even IMing or real-time screen-sharing doesn't make sense.
I know that keeping a clean history is very important, but keeping all the patches straight IMHO is even more important and git is exactly the tool for that job. Email is the wrong tool for that job aside from some very occasional "check this out, am I being stupid here?" type things.
Then again, I am not a kernel developer and have no idea what I am talking about. All I can contribute is that on small-ish projects (up to 10 people on a team), using git differently makes everyone's lives easier at the cost of the history looking slightly worse.
* Breakage is localized to small merges. Instead of debugging the breakage of 1 month of work integrated with yours, you debug it a day of work at a time. Localized/differential debugging is much easier.
* Ditto with conflicts. Dealing with daily conflicts is much easier than dealing with the aggregate of a month's conflict. Beyond a certain threshold of difficulty, conflict resolution quality becomes very low. People just give up and start resolving conflicts semi-randomly.
If you review now Linus comment, it makes sense that pulling should be done on a feature branch: one that has a complete, working solution of something you need.