News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: HN Political News Overload? by tptacek on Monday July 29, 2013 @02:36PM (#6122956)
Nobody could have written this better; I agree with every word of it, and note also that the "feedback loop" of people drawn to HN to discuss politics is a testable assertion, and the testing I've done has backed it up. When you see a political story on HN, click through to its submitter, and look at their history on the site. Not always, but often, the people behind these stories:

* Are relatively new to HN, and

* Participate in HN practically exclusively on political stories.

Another point I might add:

* Political stories drive low-quality sources up the front page. The people running sites like Techdirt and RT know exactly what to say to gin up pageviews, and so it's those sources you'll see anchoring political stories on HN. On controversial topics, people barely read blog posts as it is. But on political stories, not only do we have to deal with knee-jerk comments from people who haven't really read the source, but also with the fact that even reading the story carefully doesn't produce informed commentary (Techdirt, for instance, has a habit of linkjacking and editorializing stories from reported venues like Mother Jones and the Washington Post).

There are no comments on this comment yet.