Re:The American-Western European Values Gap
by rayiner on Monday July 29, 2013 @10:07AM
(#6121166)
> To protect your own national interests, not to promote world peace.
The U.S. does act in its own national interest, but it has taken a broader view of national interest than any major power in modern times. Rhetoric aside, it doesn't act on some abstract love of democracy. Rather, it acts on a practical commitment to preserving the status quo of the ascendency of the western democracies. And that just happens to be in the interest of much of Europe too.
> Now, before anyone says that Europeans have inflicted much more violence on the world over the course of history, I do agree with that
The tendency in Europe right now is to think that you're outside of history. That the forces that existed in Europe, embroiling it in nearly perpetual war for hundreds of years before World War II no longer exist. I'd posit that this isn't really the case. You're not different or better people now than you ever were. Something else is in play.
> No one is perfect and I don't see why Americans get so freaking defensive every time someone points out a flaw with their country.
I'm not trying to be defensive. I'm pointing out something Europeans tend to gloss over: it's easy to feel like you've turned the corner on violence and war when the U.S.'s foreign policy just happens to involve clearing all your brush fires for you. Let's not pretend. It's not like Europe doesn't benefit tremendously from U.S. attempts to maintain stability in the middle east and keep the oil flowing. It's not like Europe could afford to spend relatively little on their militaries in the face of continued Russian military power if the U.S. didn't exist as a foil. Going back further, it's not like no European country had anything to do with Vietnam...
The U.S. does act in its own national interest, but it has taken a broader view of national interest than any major power in modern times. Rhetoric aside, it doesn't act on some abstract love of democracy. Rather, it acts on a practical commitment to preserving the status quo of the ascendency of the western democracies. And that just happens to be in the interest of much of Europe too.
> Now, before anyone says that Europeans have inflicted much more violence on the world over the course of history, I do agree with that
The tendency in Europe right now is to think that you're outside of history. That the forces that existed in Europe, embroiling it in nearly perpetual war for hundreds of years before World War II no longer exist. I'd posit that this isn't really the case. You're not different or better people now than you ever were. Something else is in play.
> No one is perfect and I don't see why Americans get so freaking defensive every time someone points out a flaw with their country.
I'm not trying to be defensive. I'm pointing out something Europeans tend to gloss over: it's easy to feel like you've turned the corner on violence and war when the U.S.'s foreign policy just happens to involve clearing all your brush fires for you. Let's not pretend. It's not like Europe doesn't benefit tremendously from U.S. attempts to maintain stability in the middle east and keep the oil flowing. It's not like Europe could afford to spend relatively little on their militaries in the face of continued Russian military power if the U.S. didn't exist as a foil. Going back further, it's not like no European country had anything to do with Vietnam...