Rule of thumb: if you can quote Obama's point of view on something, it's probably politics.
(food would be a false positive, I suppose, but you wouldn't get so many other errors)
Fun fact: Obama also has an opinion on bubble sort.
The answer is "Yes" to all of these, IMO
All of those are, obviously. Don't try to avert the issue by redefining words.
All I'm asking for is a definition from as many readers as possible, because that's where a discussion is supposed to start. The (until this moment, at least) lack of a collection of definitions is actually horrifying, for me.
If we had a collection of definitions, you'd be surprised how different they all are (personally, I don't agree at all that "political post" can be defined by a list of words). Yet here we are, talking about something we haven't even clearly defined, yet.
- Is "Snowden" = politics?
- Is "NSA" = politics?
- Is "War machine" = politics?
- Is "Poverty" = politics?
- Is "Unemployment" = politics?
Let's first try to see if "everybody" has the same definition.
Then "HN management" can update their manifest so we actually do have a tangible result after this discussion.
EDIT: As of now, we still don't have an agreed-on definition for what counts as "a political post". Or am I taking this discussion too seriously? Please downvote if you feel it was a bad idea I signed up on this site, I'd like to know...