Re:Who Are We at War With? That’s Classified
by dragonwriter on Monday July 29, 2013 @01:09AM
(#6119464)
> > America is, in theory, a representative democracy ...
> America was once a republic
The two are not incompatible. And it pretty unquestionably still is a republic and, in form at least, is also a representative democracy.
Re:Who Are We at War With? That’s Classified
by Daniel_Newby on Monday July 29, 2013 @05:02PM
(#6123850)
A country with a Supreme Court that believes threshing wheat is interstate commerce is not a republic. Ditto for a country with federal bunny rabbit inspectors.
Re:Who Are We at War With? That’s Classified
by dragonwriter on Monday July 29, 2013 @05:49PM
(#6124109)
> A country with a Supreme Court that believes threshing wheat is interstate commerce is not a republic. Ditto for a country with federal bunny rabbit inspectors.
I know of no reasonable definition of "republic" under which either of these statements is defensible. "Republic" doesn't mean a system of government that produces exclusively outcomes that meet with Daniel_Newby's approval.
Re:Who Are We at War With? That’s Classified
by Daniel_Newby on Monday July 29, 2013 @11:22PM
(#6125238)
Government is not an averaging process. You cannot add oligarchy to mob rule, divide by two, and get a republic.
Re:Who Are We at War With? That’s Classified
by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:54AM
(#6125546)
that's a non-sequitur. "Republic" isn't the average of oligarchy and mob rule, or anywhere in between those. It's orthogonal to them. You certainly can have a system with strong elements of both that is a republic (as demonstrated by the essentially prototypical republic, that of Rome.)
You seem, again, to be conflating what you like with what a Republic is.
America was once a republic, precisely to avoid the madness we are talking about in this thread. One by one the protections against mob rule have been dismantled.