Re:Who Are We at War With? That’s Classified
by anigbrowl on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:07PM
(#6118658)
Because of the constitution. Suppose you are running for President, I support you, and I am rich. I rent a billboard and hang paper on it saying 'northwest for President!!' Well, the other candidate (southeast) is not happy about that, but under the first amendment there is no question that I have the right to publish my opinion that everyone should vote for you. So southeast reasonably argues that it is unfair for her to be prevented from renting a billboard, which is true. And so it goes.
This is a simplistic example, but that's basically what the famous Citizens United case was about - did a wealthy third party have the right to publish something designed to influence an election (in that case, by saying negative things about Hilary Clinton)? The first amendment says pretty clearly that Congress cannot make any law that limits the freedom of the press, and so people who want to use their money to publish election messages have to be allowed to do it.
As a European I agree that it's far from ideal, but that's something you have to accept if you want the freedoms of the first amendment as it is written.
This is a simplistic example, but that's basically what the famous Citizens United case was about - did a wealthy third party have the right to publish something designed to influence an election (in that case, by saying negative things about Hilary Clinton)? The first amendment says pretty clearly that Congress cannot make any law that limits the freedom of the press, and so people who want to use their money to publish election messages have to be allowed to do it.
As a European I agree that it's far from ideal, but that's something you have to accept if you want the freedoms of the first amendment as it is written.