Re:Ask HN: Securely store sensitive data in the DB?
by ra on Monday July 29, 2013 @05:47PM
(#6124100)
Just because it's more secure than network / file doesn't mean it's secure. That's why we have smartcards / HSMs.
Re:Ask HN: Securely store sensitive data in the DB?
by raverbashing on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @10:16AM
(#6127046)
Smartcards are vulnerable as well and there has been successful attacks towards some smartcards (google it)
And not every system has an HSM available
Re:Ask HN: Securely store sensitive data in the DB?
by ra on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @07:00AM
(#6132875)
Sure but smartcards and HSMs are slow and in a properly managed environment are much safer than memory.
Whether or not the OP has an HSM is moot. The OP said, "I want to design and implement a solution as secure as it can be" ... and that means (among many other things) keys on HSM.
If your attacker has access to arbitrary memory of a process, you're using an insecure OS/version. Or they dumped your process memory using a vulnerability (in your system)
Yes, there are some possible attacks (page file, cache, etc)
Attacking memory after a reboot requires physical access (unless you hibernated without an encrypted file, in this case...)
It certainly beats the security of file/network