News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Antibiotic resistance: The last resort by harshreality on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:15AM (#6116896)
When very bad outbreaks start to occur because antibiotics' effectiveness starts dropping precipitously, I think there will be progress. It will take a few years to get ramped up, but given modern technology I think there will be some interesting partial solutions fairly soon after that.

The Russians were particularly interested in this sort of thing during the latter part of the Cold War, as I'm sure the West was, and still is. They were looking at enhancing the immune system as an alternative to antibiotics or vaccines for agents that could not necessarily be fought with antibiotics or vaccines (i.e. biological terrorism). They also looked at using immune response as a bioterror target (e.g. something like the reaction to TGN1412 but using a transmissible bioagent instead of a non-biological agent.) They were keenly aware that the two problems were linked.

Obviously, immune response is bad at all times when there's no active threatening infection to fight, but needs to be maximized at least along certain paths when there's a threatening infection. That was a difficult problem with 1980's technology. I'm optimistic that it's not quite so intractable a problem, at least in cases of common bacterial infections typically treated with antibiotics today. More narrowly targeted immune system boosting seems plausible now that there's a somewhat better understanding of immune system interactions...

Re:Antibiotic resistance: The last resort by hga on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:40AM (#6116980)
"enhancing the immune system"

Note that one possible flip side of this is auto-immune diseases.

"immune response is bad at all times when there's no active threatening infection to fight"

I don't think that's at all true. Our immune systems tend to work wonderfully most of the time given that we're constantly bathed in potentially pathogenic bacteria. In this discussion scythe says of "the ESKAPE pathogens, which are the primary superbugs" that "in every case except S aureus, infection is basically unheard of when an individual has a functioning immune system; they are all opportunistic pathogens". I take that to mean that for a lot people, temporary immune system dysfunction, e.g. due to other insults to the body, are a big factor.

I noticed on Wikipedia that one of the ESKAPE bacteria, Acinetobacter baumannii (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acinetobacter_baumannii), "Colloquially, A. baumannii is referred to as 'Iraqibacter' due to its seemingly sudden emergence in military treatment facilities during the Iraq War. It has continued to be an issue for veterans and soldiers who serve in Iraq and Afghanistan. Multidrug resistant (MDR) A. baumannii has spread to civilian hospitals in part due to the transport of infected soldiers through multiple medical facilities."

That I assume is largely due to gross trauma (and lots more soldiers surviving because of much better body armor (even helps in non-comat accidents I've read) and ever better treatment) ... and e.g. car crashes in the US tell us we're not soon going to be rid of that problem....

Re:Antibiotic resistance: The last resort by harshreality on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:52AM (#6117008)
I realize that auto-immune disease is a consequence of overactive immune system, and I thought I alluded to that in the last paragraph. I guess I don't believe that the only way to enhance the immune system is to make it more active in general or in ways that would necessarily lead to increased instances of autoimmune disease.

I should have said wherever rather than at all times when. I don't try to discuss this a lot so I guess I'm not as precise at organizing my thoughts as I'd like to be. Thanks. Yeah, "superbugs" are disproportionately at hospitals, and garden variety bacterial species; they cause problems because patients tend to have wounds or compromised immune systems, and because the frequency of antibiotic use at hospitals encourages thriving populations of resistant strains.

Re:Antibiotic resistance: The last resort by hga on Sunday July 28, 2013 @12:06PM (#6117041)
Ah, yes, I can see that now, "[m]ore narrowly targeted immune system boosting" is definitely an option. Although ... do we want everyone in the country/world taking the same "ImmuneBoost(TM)"...? (Not a particularly useful criticism, but still something to also think about.)

Especially if we can find ways sufficiently weighted towards bacteria. The major thing that saves us with them is that their significant low level differences from eukaryotic cells, e.g. those smaller and different ribosomes that provide a handy target for various antibiotic families (they're the organelles that synthesize proteins). Or their plant style cell walls.

(I stopped paying attention to the details of immune system in the late '70s when I noted how fast we were learning about it, i.e. for me it's something to learn/review "on demand", so I can't make any really specific suggestions as to what to do or judge the feasibility.)

Re:Antibiotic resistance: The last resort by harshreality on Sunday July 28, 2013 @12:54PM (#6117193)
I'm a fan of distributed separately-evolving defenses, and identical ImmuneBoost(TM) given to everyone, that has the same effects in everyone, could I suppose create susceptibility to some HIV-style pathogen that triggers and/or hijacks the specific boosted aspects of the immune system. HIV is very careful (i.e. has evolved) to stay dormant for a long time... it probably didn't start out that way, and suffered as a result. Any sort of pathogen that targets the immune system has to be similarly careful; otherwise it suffers the same fate of all extremely lethal pathogens: killing the host population faster than it can spread.

Another promising research avenue is bacteriophages. I don't know why it's being pursued more in the former Soviet Union than it is in the West. I suppose even with targeted bacteriophages there's some risk that they could mutate and start targeting beneficial bacteria, which would be a problem.

A cute CS-inspired theoretical approach would be to throw variable layers at the problem. With genetic engineering, create bacteria that function as a supplemental immune system, but in a very narrow way; the bacteria would, possibly in collaboration with the host immune system, generate specific bacteriophages for any pathogenic bacteria they come into contact with. Obviously it wouldn't work against pathogenic viruses, but other than the (perhaps impossible) difficulty of having a cell able to generate novel bacteriophages, it doesn't seem so outlandish. If we get to the point where we can write code for a wide variety of biological activity and get it translated into DNA, then such a bacteriophage-generating bacterium might be possible.

I realize there are pathologies imaginable with any possible solution. The question is how likely is it that natural or engineered pathogens will target whatever new targets are available. Bacteriophage-generating bacteria could be hijacked by viruses, mutated by gene transfer with harmful bacteria to do bad things, or even give their bacteriophage-generating properties to pathological bacteria which might then gain mutations to generate human-targeting viruses... wouldn't that be fun.

Re:Antibiotic resistance: The last resort by DanBC on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:37AM (#6116972)
> When very bad outbreaks start to occur because antibiotics' effectiveness starts dropping precipitously, I think there will be progress.

Hospital acquired infection is a significant cause of death.

> In the United States, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimated roughly 1.7 million hospital-associated infections, from all types of microorganisms, including bacteria, combined, cause or contribute to 99,000 deaths each year.

> In Europe, where hospital surveys have been conducted, the category of Gram-negative infections are estimated to account for two-thirds of the 25,000 deaths each year.

(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hospital-acquired_infection)

These are just nosocomial (hospital acquired) and not necessarily antibiotic resistant.

Re:Antibiotic resistance: The last resort by harshreality on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:45AM (#6116993)
Resistant infections in hospitals must not yet be a significant enough problem to get lots of smart people working on the problem. Or, rather, they're working on trying to contain infections and reduce transmissions rather than on how to treat the infections, right? The other shoe has to drop before other half of the problem gets serious attention.