News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by draz on Saturday July 27, 2013 @04:48PM (#6114376)
I propose a 4th reason why they merged with Xhibit: the owners of SkyMall realized that with WiFi becoming more and more prominent on flights, bored traveler are less and less likely to flip through their magazines, but instead get online (where they'd have their own set of advertisements, shopping capabilities, etc). I think, therefore, it was the right move to cash out before companies themselves pull out of their agreements with SkyMall.
Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by cstross on Saturday July 27, 2013 @05:30PM (#6114517)
It's not just wifi on flights: if these reports are correct, the FAA is considering relaxing restrictions on electronics during take-off and landing:

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/06/stow-it-no-more-f...

If this happens, then SkyMall's market just disintegrated like a wet telephone book -- they're competing with Amazon et al from boarding to arrival at the destination gate. Even without in-flight wifi, travelers who forgot to pack a book or magazine are no longer going to be a captive audience, so that 70% eyeball share will crash.

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by larrys on Saturday July 27, 2013 @06:13PM (#6114674)
"they're competing with Amazon et al"

The product that skymall is selling is entertainment.

The value of being able to leaf through a magazine and see some interesting products. And maybe buy something you would never think of.

Just like HN is a venue to read things you might not come across in your own browsing. Skymall pushes product into easy viewing site because they are a printed magazine right at your fingertips.

Now of course you can do that online but you are in a confined space and a captive audience and that magazine has appeal plain and simple no matter what you can take a look at online. And of course you have plenty of entertainment on your tablet or laptop. But this is in a different format and it deserves at least a look.

Let me make up an outlandish example.

You have hotel wifi and a tablet in your private hotel room.

You then spot a magazine of pornographic pictures in a drawer and that type of stuff turns you on (as it does most men, right?). Even if you can view the porn online you are still going to leaf through the magazine because it's easy to do and just "take a look" for the entertainment value. (That's quite different from actually buying the same magazine in the store in the hotel).

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by pubby on Saturday July 27, 2013 @07:34PM (#6114895)
>The product that skymall is selling is entertainment.

Their advantage over amazon may be the entertainment value, but it seems improper to say they're "selling entertainment" when realistically they're selling ads. I don't see the connection to porno magazines since they're completely different business models.

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by derefr on Saturday July 27, 2013 @09:25PM (#6115178)
> it seems improper to say they're "selling entertainment" when realistically they're selling ads

SkyMall has four main assets, in two classes:

1. deals with airlines to put their magazine in the plane seat pockets (stable), and with companies to advertise in their magazine (ephemeral); and

2. cultural expertise in dealing with airlines (rare), and with selling advertising in a magazine (commonplace).†

Even though advertising is, of the two, the revenue-generating asset, the other one is a monopoly (it's an exclusive contract with a lot of venues, sort of like Ticketmaster.) So, if advertising stops working out for them, and they're going to pivot, I would imagine they'd keep the monopoly--their magazine getting put in seats--and try to find a new revenue-generating content-stream to fill that magazine with. Deciding to instead keeping the advertisers, and the advertising "business", and trying to find a new way to use them, sounds kind of braindead.

...in fact, if I were them, and I was pivoting, I'd sell off the advertising "aspect" of the business to a company that wanted some built-up advertiser relationships... hmm.

Here's some speculation: Xhibit bought SkyMall on a PE trading system, right? If Xhibit is internally thinking of itself as a PE firm in this action--and if SkyMall was frank with them about their worries that their advertising revenue-stream will go kaput--then Xhibit might be trying to split SkyMall: to absorb the advertising part of the company into itself (where they can use the advertiser relationships in digital-media industries), pivot the magazine into something else, make it profitable doing that something else, and then sell off the magazine, like any other PE firm.

This also, sort of, explains why Xhibit has so many nascent ventures; what could be going on is that, since they're absorbing SkyMall's advertiser base, they're just asking those advertisers what extra services (beyond just magazine ads) they would pay for--and then setting out to build them.

---

† (Also, expertise in the logistics of getting a magazine printed and into the hands of airlines, but that's not much relevant either way.)

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by cstross on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:27AM (#6116150)
I've been out of the print magazine biz for a long time, and was only an editorial content supplier at best, but the figures SkyMall was charging for quarter-page or full-page ads in their magazine were eye-watering. For a top 5 newsstand computer magazine in the US I'd have expected $10-15K/page; SkyMall were pushing an order of magnitude above that, presumably because of the size of the market but also the captive nature of the audience.

A secondary issue: most people don't look at the ads in magazines for entertainment unless there's no other entertainment option available. SkyMall had the privileged position of being the only eyeball candy to hand for millions of flyers who weren't allowed to use their laptops or tablets or phones at certain times, and who hadn't thought to buy an emergency magazine or paper book. (Full disclosure: I'm often one of them.) I suspect games or ebooks or emagazines will prove vastly more attractive than a SkyMall catalog, so what's going to drop is the number of eyeballs on pages, which will eventually bite into the first-time-buyer stats for the advertisers, with indirect knock-on effects on the SkyMall business as a whole.

The advertiser-relationship side of the business is indeed likely to stay viable, and Xhibit has bought a buttload of goodwill business, but the magazine is almost certainly going to become non-viable as soon as iPads are legal during take-off and landing and especially if a price war breaks out between airlines over in-flight wifi.

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by jarrett on Saturday July 27, 2013 @06:16PM (#6114683)
As the owners of SkyMall, how would you cash out on this deal? As I understand it, Xhibit didn't pay cash for SkyMall. I take this to be a stock-for-stock merger. So the owners of SkyMall end up with a stake in Xhibit but not cash.

You might argue that the SkyMall people could sell their stock now. But if Xhibit is as much of s sham as the authors say, then it's going to be hard or impossible to cash out at a good price. Once you start selling the shares of an artificially inflated company, the price falls fast. You might unload a few at a high price, but just a few.

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by UnoriginalGuy on Saturday July 27, 2013 @04:53PM (#6114396)
I think you're massively overstating how common WiFi is. First off it only exists over certain land areas, and secondly it is so costly on most flights few are paying for it ($35 for a 60 minute flight? Uhh no thanks).

Plus you'd still read Skymall during takeoff/landing where electronic devices are banned.

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by jmathai on Saturday July 27, 2013 @05:10PM (#6114447)
I think you're massively underestimating the future trend. More flights will have wifi for cheaper. Not less for more money.

Sure, from the looks of today it might not seem like a big disruption for SkyMall but it will.

On most flights I go on I'd say about 10-20% of the folks have a tablet device. That trend will also go up and continue to decrease the effectiveness of SkyMall.

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by throwaway1979 on Saturday July 27, 2013 @05:19PM (#6114471)
On what basis do you claim that "most flights will have wifi for cheaper"? There really isn't much competition when you are at 10,000 feet. Also, if airlines wanted to differentiate themselves based on quality, they had ample opportunity to do so. From my understanding, for coach seats in the US, airlines compete solely based on price.
Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by marvin on Saturday July 27, 2013 @06:30PM (#6114735)
European low-cost airline Norwegian currently has free wi-fi on all their European flights. I'm pretty sure this trend will continue - it's a relatively inexpensive way for airlines to differentiate themselves from their competition.
Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by jmathai on Sunday July 28, 2013 @12:24AM (#6115601)
I doubt wifi will get more expensive or be less common on airplanes in 4 years. But sure, assume it will. SkyMall would still have to compete with tablets that passengers carry.

I can't site a research paper to back this up though.

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by throwaway9848 on Sunday July 28, 2013 @12:50AM (#6115668)
Great thought. That's why SkyMall (profitable, $100M+ revenue) should merge with an unprofitable reverse-merger OTC trading company that is unprofitable with $10M trailing revenue on 40/60 terms.

Instead of doing that, maybe they could have hired technical staff and built a mobile app themselves?

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by draz on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:41AM (#6116518)
I actually thought of that, but I realized that BoingBoing (and the like) beat them to it but being the gatekeeper to the internet. From last I've seen, they have their own shopping portal (and Amazon was access was complimentary). Why would I go out of my way to download the SkyMall app? What value would it give me?
Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by jmathai on Monday July 29, 2013 @01:30PM (#6122533)
The only way I see that working is if the airline somehow made it possible to install the SkyMall app and use it. Providing the app exclusive access to communicate back down to earth.

I know it's possible because the last flight I was on did it for Ebay. You could surf Ebay for free without having to pay for Wifi.

I wouldn't be on this approach working for SkyMall though.

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 27, 2013 @05:17PM (#6114468)
The people likely to pay for WiFi are also likely to be valuable Skymall customers. E.g. I always buy WiFi on domestic flights and haven't touched an issue of Skymall in years. I have, however, made Amazon purchases while flying.
Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by moistgorilla on Saturday July 27, 2013 @05:25PM (#6114496)
On delta I've been paying around 5 dollars for flight long wifi
Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by rhizome on Saturday July 27, 2013 @05:28PM (#6114507)
Next time you're on a flight, scroll down on the wifi rates. I noticed that the top option was something like you mention, $35 or whatever per day. However, a few packages below the "per day" rate was a "duration of the flight" rate that was somewhat cheaper, like half or less.
Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by jthol on Saturday July 27, 2013 @05:57PM (#6114615)
from http://www.southwest.com/wifi/

> Internet access will be available for $8 all day, per device and will be displayed once you launch your internet browser and connect above 10,000 feet*.

This trend will continue and expand.

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by ecspike on Saturday July 27, 2013 @05:38PM (#6114551)
On many of the airlines that have Wifi, Delta has it on most of their mainline fleet, also have free ebay or amazon even if you don't get the wifi.

The cost is closer to $12-15 for a long haul and as little as $5-7 for a mobile device or shorthaul or with a coupon pack.

Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by 27182818284 on Saturday July 27, 2013 @05:11PM (#6114453)
Well it doesn't have to be 100% right now for people to be able to read the writing on the wall, right? They can look at trends and see Wifi adoption going up and legitimately worry about it even though not a lot of flights today have Wifi.
Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by mikeash on Saturday July 27, 2013 @06:29PM (#6114731)
Satellite-based global coverage is becoming a reality. Lufthansa, for example, has coverage on some transatlantic flights. United is currently in the process of installing WiFi on every flight, including over-water flights.
Re:SkyMall's SkyFall by jsight on Saturday July 27, 2013 @07:06PM (#6114820)
I've been on flights where inflight wifi was $$, but inflight WiFi access to Skymall was free. I don't think the growing availability of Wifi will hurt them among the type of people who buy their overpriced (and often useless) merchandise.