News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can Software That Predicts Crime Pass Constitutional Muster? by adventured on Saturday July 27, 2013 @01:51PM (#6113743)
If it's based on crime statistics, this software would be heavily oriented toward black communities. My guess is that will be regarded as racist / profiling. I think even more than a Constitutional issue, you're going to run into social sensitivities around profiling.
Re:Can Software That Predicts Crime Pass Constitutional Muster? by DannyBee on Saturday July 27, 2013 @02:14PM (#6113819)
The thing about these statistics is that they are usually statistics on where reported crimes occur, and reported crimes of certain types.

Crime is essentially infinite these days. I could walk down the street in any neighborhood, and in the vast multitude of federal and state statutes, I would feel comfortable that i could arrest every single person i met for something.

Maybe they wouldn't get convicted. But i would legally be able to arrest them.

So then the question becomes "what kinds of crimes do we want o prevent, and where do these occur", that is what gets you into profiling, because it is actually profiling. You are making value judgements about what kinds of crimes you want to be looking for. Because of socioeconomic and other statuses, the offender profiles for these crimes differ, etc.

Even if you only make the value judgements, and do so blind to race, it's still profiling, just "offender profiling" rather than "racial profiling".

Re:Can Software That Predicts Crime Pass Constitutional Muster? by wisty on Saturday July 27, 2013 @02:44PM (#6113919)
It might be less heavily oriented toward black communities than gut instinct, though.
Re:Can Software That Predicts Crime Pass Constitutional Muster? by gngeal on Saturday July 27, 2013 @04:50PM (#6114386)
If it's based on crime statistics, this software would be heavily oriented toward black communities.

So what? On what else than crime statistics do you propose to build a predictive system for crime? It doesn't matter which communities it picks as risky, people in those communities will scream "bloody murder" no matter what community we'd be talking about.