Mutations don't have to occur at the point of their necessity. Mutations that survive can be survivorship-neutral (or nearly so), but suddenly become useful many years later during condition changes, and thus become dominant.
Take eye colour. As far as I'm aware, aside from random sexual preference, there's no real survivorship benefit to have a particular colour eyes. So we have populations with various different colour eyes. If aliens who hate people who don't have blue eyes show up and kill everyone without blue eyes, that mutation suddenly becomes selective.
The mutations that help species survive changes in conditions are usually already there when the change shows up.
"It is generally believed that the K-Pg extinction was triggered by a massive comet/asteroid impact and its catastrophic effects on the global environment, including a lingering impact winter..."
Same page then suggests volcanic activity, etc is a less popular theory.
http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/animal_fore...
It's not enough that an asteroid hit the Earth, but it's such a simple theory that everyone can remember, it has been popularized by everyone.
I did assume however that volcanic activity could've been as a result of the impact.
To go with your Arctic tern example, just because one bird can dive deeper doesn't guarantee it's survival. It might still get eaten by a predator or catch a disease or just have a run of bad luck that causes it to starve. However, the birds that can't dive as deeply run the same risks (assuming there's no additional risk to diving deeply) and, over a long time and with a large population of birds, those that can dive deeper will survive to breed more often, until eventually the whole population carries that trait.
Because a tendency to hibernate is likely negative for survivorship when it's not necessary - if lots of other animals are moving around and you aren't, then something is more likely to come and kill you.
On the other hand, lots of animals have other varying traits that aren't obviously useful, but don't exact a significant enough toll to cause them to disappear.
> But why would you already have the ability to hibernate efficiently if you don't need it
Doesn't that assume that bears were transported into Canada and survived because they could hibernate? Isn't it perfectly possible that they moved further north gradually, increasing their tendency to sleep in cold conditions as they did so?
Imagine there's a life and death surprise test on evolution. Demonstrate knowledge and you live. Fail to do so and you die. Part of the population already has a reasonable understanding of it. Others don't. You're looking at it from the perspective of the less knowledgeable cramming their study to pass the test. Evolution in this contrived case can select for those who already happen to understand the topic.
Incorrect - it's both. Obviously adaptivity to rapid changes is key, but species don't only disappear/change due to extinction-level immediate events. Individuals also get edged out by their peers (or members of other species) who manage to outcompete them just that little bit for food, or sexual attractiveness, or any of many other reasons.
Species go extinct all the time and the original statement about "hey this one species isn't evolving in front of my eyes so evolution isn't a thing" is an old argument about evolution that has been disproved a million times.
You are just creating strawmen to support your belief. Evolution theory is not even confined to biology. You can watch it life in computer simulations if you want to.
No strawman here, how long did it take for birds to evolve ability to fly ? A few days ?
Why don't you go grab a book about evolution theory that explains all those things?
I don't know how long it took to evolve flight, but it doesn't really matter. I could guess: flying underwater is a lot easier than in air, because you can drift even if your wings (fins) don't really help you control your direction much.
The first animals that could fly above land probably couldn't fly like today's birds either. Perhaps they could only drift a little while jumping from a tree. Or perhaps they were tiny animals that could actually float in the air (on a smaller scale it works), so that forming half working wings was some advantage already. The reality is probably something else, as I said, I don't really know.
You could pose billions of questions of that kind about evolution (why did animals evolve to do this and that, and how). Just because a random evolutionist can't answer every such question doesn't mean it is wrong. It just means you have to look up the answer yourself, or research it yourself. Biology is not a finished field of research.
I've read the books that's why I see the paradox. I'm not playing games, if there are factual answers I would not be asking questions here. If an animal could survive for thousands of years without hibernating there would be no reason for it. It could even prove disastrous making the animal easy prey.
Moreover the dynamics of traveling underwater and flying in air are different. Features that are great for flight are not so great for traversing underwater for an extended period of time. There are animals that can glide today, but even there ability to glide has to evolve, and during that evolutionary process an evolving glider is a disadvantage. It is not neutral, it slows the animal down. If you are going to debate with conviction your answer should not be "I don't really know".
Yes, biology is far finished so let's not pretend like it is.
Can't write longer replies now because I only have a phone atm.
To illustrate Arctic terns are dying because they are not able to adapt to climate change. Arctic terns eat herrings a cold water fish, as the water gets warmer, these fish seek colder waters, possible by going deeper in the waters. According to biologist other birds in the Arctic can dive deeper to grab the cold water fish Arctic terns cannot, so they and their chicks starve to death. This is natural selection, there is no time to adapt via mutations, adaptations must happening quickly.