News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The perils of online college learning by visarga on Saturday July 27, 2013 @02:33AM (#6112068)
> Anyone who has come into personal contact with an inspiring professor at the top of his or her field knows that the experience can't be reproduced by remote control.

I was in Andrew Ng's first class of Machine Learning. He is one of the best professors I have ever had the pleasure to learn from, online or offline. He can transmit his passion for machine learning plenty well through video.

It's not the medium. It's some of the professors that teach online courses that haven't risen up to the standard imposed in the first classes.

If it's going to be an online class for millions, then at least find the most inspirational speaker you can before starting to record. Coursera has grown up too fast for its own good, probably many classes are just so-and-so.

Then the author goes on to say:

> My own entire graduate school experience was made worthwhile by a single extraordinary teacher, without whom it might have been an utter waste of time.

Exactly what I thought. Many people pass through brick-and-mortar universities wasting most of the time and money. It's not like real life education has magic. All it has is a real life person monitoring your presence in the lecture hall. It is just a little bit of motivation that is added on top.

We could simulate that with human monitoring - we don't need professors to monitor people taking online classes. We could do with "coaches"/people with psychological skill that would also have access to the students' online stats and have regular contact with the students.

Everybody works better when their efforts are being acknowledged. We are social animals and rely a lot on the social signals to build our motivation. So, why don't we just think of a way to have this aspect of offline learning in MOOCs?

Re:The perils of online college learning by Zigurd on Saturday July 27, 2013 @12:35PM (#6113497)
Recently my son and I were watching Sussman's 6.001 SICP lectures on YouTube. That has the effect of enabling my son to see what I learned decades ago from a very inspiring professor, and in period costume. It makes we wish there were videos of Doc Edgerton teaching Strobe Lab.

It seems as if the reason for the "failure" of the SJ State experiment is that they underestimated the fall-off rate. That may be an indicator something was wrong with the courses, or there might be nothing at all wrong with the courses and that's the fall-off rate you get at a $150 price. The article doesn't give a hint.

The real threats to MOOCs probably come from the threat of cheating debasing the value of degrees and certifications that use MOOCs. But if the quality of assignment grading and exams can be kept high, the fall-off rate mentioned in the article is just a characteristic to be managed.