What does the Haskell version do that the Python doesn’t? In terms of externally observable behaviour they both prompt for inputs and then add them up. In terms of design they’re both infinite loops that maintain one item of state.
I understand that the example was written to show the State monad, and obviously the same externally observable behaviour could be achieved in other ways in this simple case. My point is that in imperative languages you get that State behaviour for free, and unlike the simplified alternatives to the Haskell that rely on recursion instead, such as the one you posted, the imperative state-for-free model scales up when you start to get lots of state and mutation going on. It doesn’t start to suffer in performance metrics like speed or memory usage, nor does it start to have unpredictable performance characteristics in complex systems.
As I’ve stated elsewhere in this thread, this argument is not meant to belittle Haskell or dismiss the clear advantages its model offers. I’m arguing that there is a price to making those things as explicit as Haskell does, and that price is probably too high for mainstream industrial acceptance, so if we’re going to reap the benefits of the sound foundations on an industry-wide scale, they need to be available more transparently.
The problem is that the imperative model places the entire burden in the programmers head (even when it may not even be code you wrote!) whereas the Haskell version makes everything explicit.