Re:Free email address validation API for web forms
by grey-area on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:05PM
(#6110577)
A surprising number of people mistype their email addresses - if you can cut that down, it cuts down a lot on unnecessary bounced traffic, and the support costs of explaining to users that they've used the wrong email address to sign up with.
I appreciate your point that email addresses are allowed to include all kinds of wacky characters, but if the check simply triggers a warning to double check the address, and doesn't block registration, I don't see the harm in doing it - it reduces a lot of unnecessary problems for ordinary users signing up and making mistakes who don't have addresses like the one above.
Re:Free email address validation API for web forms
by alexk on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:08PM
(#6110596)
Hi lucb1e, thanks for finding this issues. It actually gets validated correctly by our parser (which will soon be open source) but hits a bug in our API. We are working on a fix right now.
Re:Free email address validation API for web forms
by dsmithn on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:41PM
(#6110758)
@gmailcom is invalid but doesn't suggest @gmail.com, might be another improvement.
Re:Free email address validation API for web forms
by alexk on Friday July 26, 2013 @07:19PM
(#6111095)
Thanks!
Re:Free email address validation API for web forms
by jodrellblank on Saturday July 27, 2013 @08:05AM
(#6112620)
Unfortunately this is broken just like all other attempts I've ever seen.
Unfortunately you didn't read the blog like most other commentors posting about ridiculously unusable but otherwise valid addresses:
"""Our goal is not to make a perfect address validator that can validate every single address that has ever been created. Our goal is to build a realistic address validator for the types of addresses we see everyday."""
If this is true: http://i.snag.gy/RSwiG.jpg
Then explain why the e-mail is arriving: http://i.snag.gy/gWPn5.jpg
Sure this is an extreme edge-case, but this was my second test. Who knows what else it rejects. Actually, why do we validate email addresses anyway? Whynot just try and send that validation email that you're going to send anyway? And on top of that, why would I ever trust a free third party service to check all my user's addresses?