Re:U.S. Tells Russia It Won’t Torture or Kill Snowden
by dragonwriter on Friday July 26, 2013 @01:31PM
(#6109352)
This would probably be a more valuable reassurance if the US didn't have a very well-known recent history of:
1. Committing acts widely accepted as being torture within the definition of international agreements to which the US while denying that they are "torture", and
2. Farming out torture/murder of persons under control of the US to third party states, and
3. Being caught red-handed misrepresenting everything it thinks it can get away with about the Snowden case.
All of which makes it so that, taken together, no reasonable party could trust:
1. Any statement made by the US regarding Snowden that comes without external confirmation or securities.
2. Any commitment of the US not to torture to have any substantive meaning, insofar the US has demonstrated that it has no problem redefining torture to exclude whatever it does.
3. Any commitment of the US not to torture or kill someone delivered into its power to mean that the US will not cause them to be tortured or killed, insofar as the US has demonstrated that it has no reluctance to render persons under its control for torturing and killing.
That's not to say that I think the US government would torture or kill Snowden, because I don't think that that is likely (for reasons unrelated to any guarantees provided by the US government.) But I do think that the US government's word on that matter, given recent history, is absolutely worthless.
All of which makes it so that, taken together, no reasonable party could trust: 1. Any statement made by the US regarding Snowden that comes without external confirmation or securities. 2. Any commitment of the US not to torture to have any substantive meaning, insofar the US has demonstrated that it has no problem redefining torture to exclude whatever it does. 3. Any commitment of the US not to torture or kill someone delivered into its power to mean that the US will not cause them to be tortured or killed, insofar as the US has demonstrated that it has no reluctance to render persons under its control for torturing and killing.
That's not to say that I think the US government would torture or kill Snowden, because I don't think that that is likely (for reasons unrelated to any guarantees provided by the US government.) But I do think that the US government's word on that matter, given recent history, is absolutely worthless.