It's "you do something 'voluntarily' now, which there'll be absolutely no democratic oversight over, or we force you". So instead of getting a nasty filtering system subject to freedom of information queries and parliamentary inquiries, we get a system where we are subject to the whims of these businesses, who will all point to the government and say "ask them", while the government will point to it being something the companies added "voluntarily".
Frankly, "voluntary regulation" like this should always be a massive warning flag.
It was a court order imposed by a judge for a specific case brought by the recording industries against the few largest ISPs individually. Part of the case was basically that the ISPs already had filtering systems in place (in that case for the IWF child abuse blocks - again, not required by law but installed "voluntarily"). So the industry essentially said that adding TPB to the existing blocklist wouldn't be too much of a burden.
(I believe that similar orders have expanded it to cover a few more sites since, but not sure whether those cover all the same ISPs again).
The government is proposing that they may bring legislation to Parliament if the industry doesn't do something to thinkofthechildren, but what shape that might take is not yet clear.