News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Universe Full of Planets by vidarh on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:31AM (#6107193)
Here's a few more that I find fascinating:

H) They do give a shit, but they are busy hiding. Consider this: If there's only one civilisation out there sufficiently advanced to be able to accelerate large, heavy objects towards others at sufficient speed, and who has decided that clobbering everyone else is their best bet at long term survival, everyone else better hide unless/until able to throw rocks first. A sufficiently large object constantly accelerated over a distance of light years would be near impossible to protect against.

The solution might very well be that anyone chatty gets hit by a planet.

I) Something natural periodically wipes life out. E.g. consider if gamma-ray bursts occurs frequently enough, and are powerful enough, to cut down everyone that don't reach an extremely high technological level in a very short timespan.

J) We're in a simulation and they're not interested in simulating life on other planets (or the purpose is to simulate a universe with life only on earth).

Re:A Universe Full of Planets by Balgair on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:20PM (#6110352)
Awesome!

Hiding has few benefits though. We can see them, and they can see us. It just takes a big telescope. The time lags are the big problems still. Say they can send a school bus at us at 0.9c. That'll still take a few hundred years or so to get to us. We have plenty of time to skedaddle or send our own school bus at their's. And we'll always see it coming too. In fact, just as in any hard problem you want more minds on the task. A different view point, or math method, or formulation of chemistry or art, will be a great benefit to you. Considering that you will never actually "shake hands" talking is the only thing you can do.

Hmm, actually, I wonder if the interstellar ham radio network is more like the internet than a semaphore network, aka full of trolls. Guess we have to find out.

I am pretty in favor of the periodic angel of death argument. The conditions for life on earth are incredibly rare as is. So the conditions to not have a GRB near us are also even more rare. The odd asteroid, charismatic lunatic with nukes and a grudge, disease, suicide cult, volcano etc amplify the fragility of a continued intelligence.

I don't believe that a simulation is a good thing to bet on. It would be nice to think my thoughts are archived in a giant blobbery computer somewhere in the 4th dimension, but all evidence points to us actually being here. This gets to swirl the great toilet hole of existentialism really quick, so i prefer not to look at it a whole lot.