News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How Should We Treat Each Other Here? by adamc on Friday May 15, 2009 @09:36AM (#610516)
Just for myself: most of the smarta$$ remarks waste my time. I'm looking for interesting information, and they don't provide any.
Re:Ask HN: How Should We Treat Each Other Here? by physcab on Friday May 15, 2009 @01:22PM (#610944)
Is anyone else getting sick of all the "Ask HN: [complaining]" threads?

I understand the situation. People need to chill out. If you've got some beef with another user, just contact them personally.

I, like you, just want to read interesting things. Maybe there should be a sticky thing like in other forums for personal conduct expectations.

Re:Ask HN: How Should We Treat Each Other Here? by amackera on Friday May 15, 2009 @02:55PM (#611128)
If there is one thing above all else that hackers love to do, it's self-reflect. The "Ask HN" threads are just extending this self-reflection to this special something we all love and enjoy (HN!).
Re:Ask HN: How Should We Treat Each Other Here? by badger7 on Friday May 15, 2009 @03:23PM (#611168)
There's a world of difference between self-reflection and self-congratulation, seldom noticed by those practising the latter.
Re:Ask HN: How Should We Treat Each Other Here? by boundlessdreamz on Friday May 15, 2009 @11:13AM (#610721)
Exactly. The problem is that "smart$$ comments" are easier to write than a thoughtful reply. So pretty soon everyone gets into a game of one upmanship and every thread will have 80% "smart$$ comments". This why I no longer read reddit comments. On slashdot I browse at +5 keeping out much of the noise. Thankfully in HN, I was relieved to know that such comments are not tolerated by majority.

I have downvoted quite a lot of "smart$$" comments but never something that added original thought. I come to HN for comments that educate, inform and make me think. If i wanted a good laugh I would go to bash.org

Re:Ask HN: How Should We Treat Each Other Here? by Angostura on Friday May 15, 2009 @02:59PM (#611133)
That's why on Slashdot a +1 Funny vote will not earn the poster any karma.
Re:Ask HN: How Should We Treat Each Other Here? by trickjarrett on Friday May 15, 2009 @11:11AM (#610718)
A corollary. As you noted, humor on its own is usually regarded as noise in the HN environment, but if it is tagged onto an insightful comment then it tends to be better received.
Re:Ask HN: How Should We Treat Each Other Here? by tptacek on Friday May 15, 2009 @12:44PM (#610890)
You know what's even less valuable than smarta$$ remarks? Dumba$$ responses to them. I disagree with edw519; not all downmods require explanatory comments.
Re:Ask HN: How Should We Treat Each Other Here? by Radix on Friday May 15, 2009 @11:10AM (#610715)
I don't know. Generally I agree, but did you see this http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35079 I don't know anywhere else that this would have happened. On HN if it isn't genuinely funny then it gets voted down so I'm ok with it. I made a completely useless comment yesterday that was down voted; I won't do that again so easily.
Re:Ask HN: How Should We Treat Each Other Here? by russell on Friday May 15, 2009 @12:58PM (#610911)
Same experience for me, but the HN karma system has made me a more thoughtful commenter. Humor within a substantive comment is a whole lot more work than a one-liner, but I'll work at it.