News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by VladRussian2 on Thursday July 25, 2013 @05:28PM (#6105127)
>Medieval torture is a bad example because it was done with the intent of causing pain. This is not.

Jews in concentration camps were experimented on with intent of scientific experiment. By your standard it is just ok.

Intent doesn't matter to the subject of torture, be it an interrogated witch, 911 terrorist, Jew in concentration camp being experimented on or a dog being vivisected.

> Today the idea is repugnant, but that's because we have analgesics we can use.

No. The idea became repugnant to some [the most advanced people of the time] and through their effort the analgesics started to be used. In particular, ether was first used for surgery in 1846, while vivisection was still legal for more than half a century after that.

Or do you mean UCSF doesn't have analgesics available:

http://www.sfgate.com/education/article/UCSF-lapses-mean-res...

> Once we get a better tool we'll use it, but don't criticize the past for not using a tool that didn't exist.

That a convenient lie - alcohol, 'shrooms, opium, various barks, cola nut, etc... have been known for like thousands years.

>Even worse would be to say not to do the experiment at all.

False scare, like security vs. liberty. The humanity would probably be much better off if it excluded all experiments on live animals. Our primitive, medieval, violent mentality is that keeps us from developing into advanced civilization. Live and let live.

Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by ars on Thursday July 25, 2013 @06:58PM (#6105499)
> Jews in concentration camps were experimented on with intent of scientific experiment.

No they weren't. They were experimented on with the intent of causing pain. If you really believe that the intent was science then you owe it to yourself to learn more history.

> Intent doesn't matter to the subject of torture

Yes it does. If the intent is pain then pain will be maximized. If the intent is learning then pain will be minimized, or at least not increased.

UCSF seem incompetent and negligent, but why are you using them as an example? There are always bad actors. You need to look at the normal, not the extreme.

> alcohol, 'shrooms, opium, various barks, cola nut, etc... have been known for like thousands years.

We know now that they could have used it. Yet from every account I've read they didn't. They had opium, yet did surgery without it. So despite theoretically having it, practically speaking, they didn't.

> The humanity would probably be much better off if it excluded all experiments on live animals.

If by better off you mean die young then I guess so.

> Our primitive, medieval, violent mentality is that keeps us from developing into advanced civilization.

Our "primitive, medieval, violent mentality" are what is causing us to advance. Peaceful non-competitive societies never progress. And what's primitive about it anyway? Do you consider yourself primitive? No? They why do you think anyone else is?

Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by VladRussian2 on Thursday July 25, 2013 @07:10PM (#6105553)
>No they weren't. They were experimented on with the intent of causing pain. If you really believe that the intent was science then you owe it to yourself to learn more history

man, are you serious or just doesn't know anything or just trolling?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_human_experimentation

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731

the rest of your statements are about the same. I'll just stop here.

Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by russellsprouts on Thursday July 25, 2013 @08:19PM (#6105859)
The experiments they did had no real scientific value. Nominally, they were doing research, but it wasn't rigorous or useful results.
Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by sesqu on Friday July 26, 2013 @12:13AM (#6106557)
That's not entirely accurate. Many experiments were useless, notably Mengele's, but some data collected remains useful (though not necessarily used) to this day. There were results by others that were applicable, usually regarding weapon development and exposure to elements.

And while we're on the topic, the US experimented on their interned populace as well, though with less intent to harm, as did the Japanese (referenced by GP).

Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by ars on Thursday July 25, 2013 @08:21PM (#6105868)
Wow. It's not often I come across someone who is willfully ignorant. You even link to sources!

Did you even read those very things you linked to?

Not only do you know of one case of torture you know of two! And still somehow believe they were intended as experiments and not intended for pain.

Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by TeMPOraL on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:50AM (#6107222)
I read and I disagree with you.

> And still somehow believe they were intended as experiments and not intended for pain.

How about: they were intended as experiment, but Jews were treated as disposable experimental material, just like we treat rats today? Because hey, it's a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to test crazy theories on real humans without regard to consequences. And maybe help the soldiers win the war!

Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by ars on Saturday July 27, 2013 @10:36PM (#6115373)
That's just not the case though.

They were intended for pain - the "experiment" was an afterthought "hey! we are already torturing them, lets get some data out of it too".

Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by aperrien on Thursday July 25, 2013 @06:19PM (#6105356)
This philosophical argument can be answered very simply. Which do you value more, animals or humans?
Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by PavlovsCat on Thursday July 25, 2013 @07:07PM (#6105533)
If you actually value either, you also have to value the other?

But I can also answer that with a question if you want: which do you value more, slow but steady progress, and planting for generations ahead and reaping from what generations before sowed, or instant gratification and profit, and the constant low-intensity war that entails? (not that we lack a constancy of military action in the world, but hey)

Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by ars on Thursday July 25, 2013 @08:25PM (#6105879)
> If you actually value either, you also have to value the other?

If by value you mean assign a positive number then No. If by value you mean calculate then Yes. (Sorry for phrasing it that way, but I wasn't sure which you meant.)

> which do you value more, slow but steady progress, and planting for generations ahead and reaping from what generations before sowed, or instant gratification and profit, and the constant low-intensity war that entails?

Now I'm confused. In another post you appear to be against this experiment (i.e. the slow and steady progress), but the way you write this makes it look like the slow and steady progress is the better way - but that's the experiment.

So which is it?

Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by VladRussian2 on Thursday July 25, 2013 @06:43PM (#6105444)
>This philosophical argument can be answered very simply.

it is not philosophical, it is routine everyday choice everyone of us make. Like these researchers at UCSF - whether to administer analgesics or not before cutting a body part - calling it a philosophical question clearly shows your own philosophy.

>Which do you value more, animals or humans?

By asking such a question you already stated your answer. I don't ask nor answer such a question as i don't assign specific value points on lives of humans or animals. Putting such specific values and compare them has always been leading humans who think of themselves as of higher value to mindlessly butcher, torture, etc... anybody whom they think of as of lesser value, be it humans or animals.

Re:Fake memory implanted in mice with a beam of light by yew on Friday July 26, 2013 @02:17AM (#6106880)
It is not philosophical, it is routine everyday choice every one of us make.

There is no answer that's not philosophical. Refusing to quantify your philosophy is philosophical.

It amounts to asserting that taking a position is wrong when only people who disagree with the philosophy you implicitly accept are taking a position, so it's also rather hostile.