CouchDB solves a subset of information problems. The relational model can solve a vastly greater amount of problems.
Unfortunately, simple and stylish doesn't always win. I see lots of people riding fixed gear bikes in Seattle, for example. Actually, I don't see many people riding them, I see them walking them around because they have the wrong gearing for going up and down Seattle's many hills, and they can't actually ride them. In this case, simple and stylish is the wrong tool for the job -- they need a bike that can change gears. That may be inelegant, but it works really well.
CouchDB is the fixed gear bicycle of the database world.
To push the analogy further, some of the buzz around couchDB reminds me of people obsessed with scaling (racing) without either any real understanding of algorithms (being in shape) or any chance of actually needing it (actually competing). That starts to sound more like a road cyclist with an expensive garage ornament, though... Fixed gear bikes are perhaps more like SQLite than couchDB, in that sense. They're actually really useful on a smaller scale.
I see where you're coming from on the hipster bit, just nitpicking.
His point was that for -his- purposes CouchDB is not a convincing option for the backend object store to KiokuDB, with detailed explanations as to why.
I don't really understand why "this tool doesn't work for me and here's why" makes you a bad person - if he was saying why RDBMSes didn't work for his problem space and thus why he was using an OODB at all, I'm sure the comments would be very different.
edit: in case it's not clear, I like couchdb a lot and I think it's absurd that people people are backlashing against it because some monkey coder dorks found it highly buzzword compliant and are making it popular, despite not understanding it at all. So you end up with people hating something because it's getting some limelight for whatever reason, and then also many of the people championing it don't know how to use it correctly to build an app or anything. It's like two layers of stupid.