Why are you comparing a bad developer from Croatia with a good one from somewhere else( USA I assume ). The situation might as well be reversed, you can't assume someones skill from their geographical location.
You most certainly can. I can tell you that the average developer hired from India will have a significantly reduced skillset than one hired in the US. If that's not polite in civilized company, well then, tough.
That said, it's largely irrelevant. What's truly relevant are culture differences and you do not want to deal with them. Hire locally. If you're in Croatia, hire in Croatia. If you're in India, hire in India. If you're in the US, hire in the US. The reduced amount of grief and clear communication is worth it. Never-mind that you're in the same timezone as well.
From their geographic location, I can assume that they are likely to charge significantly less than me.
From the quality of just plain not being me, I can assume they aren't as good as me. I have yet to have experience prove this assumption wrong.
I've worked on projects with other developers in San Diego, Chicago, Miami, Iran, India, Croatia, and many other places. They've all been pretty crappy developers whom I can only imagine lied about their credentials, because I just can't imagine how it is possible they make any software for anyone. The client has eventually fired them all because they realized what a bad deal they were. The only difference between them was the hourly rate they charged, meaning there were often more from India than San Diego.
That said, I spent 2 months in San Francisco this summer and was able to find a job for higher rate just because I was there. I guess it comes with territory. :)
On the other hand you cant say about quality. Ya India has lots of crappy developers, but that is just because there are way to many developers. Good ones dont need to market themselves too much and hence most people would have never heard about them outside their circle of clients.
Maybe it's a vestige of a pseudofeudalistic time in which one measured their worth relative to the worth of their master. "You plow the fields owned by IBM? Well! My lord and master is GOOGLE. He makes your puny duchy look like PeopleSoft. FOR THE EMPIRE!!!"
My take-home pay is higher than it was working 50+ hours for salary at the hotshot San Francisco success story where I was working last year -- and I don't even have Bay Area clients, at the moment. People in Oregon and Washington are paying me this well.
I charge extra for anything I don't want to do. It's $300/hr for VB6, Crystal Reports, or MS Access stuff. I know the client can get someone else to do it cheaper. They frequently tell me as such, clearly missing the point that I want them to get someone else to do that shit. There is no way that stuff helps my long term development.
No, I don't stay 100% active with these prices. I have a steady 20 hours a week of work at $100/hr. Does that make me more or less rich than a person working 40 hours a week at $50/hr? Hard work is for suckers.
People complain about me being expensive until I release the first milestone. After that, they tend to shut up about the price. What's cheaper, a $25/hr developer from Croatia who takes 6 months to deliver the project, or a $100/hr developer who takes 2 weeks, with the added bonus that it actually works?
Something that always bothered me when I was a working stiff: I was always evaluated for pay based on how old I was, whether or not I was married with kids, and whether or not I owned my own house. No, no, no, you pay me based on what I can do, not on what I need. That's why (amongst many other ethics-related reasons) I consult now.