Re:Democratic establishment unmasked: prime defenders of NSA...
by dragonwriter on Thursday July 25, 2013 @12:34PM
(#6103284)
> You can bicker about the words "pure" and/or "tyranny" all you want
The distinction between "pure" tyranny of corporations and the less-pure tyranny (because it was tempered by potential democracy) in government was the whole of the Chomsky quote, so its not "bickering" to point out that the tyranny of corporations cannot be any more "pure" than that of the sponsoring government.
> but the point would be the same if he had said "have a strict top-down flow of authority"
Corporations do not inherently have a strict top-down flow of authority. Labor cooperatives are still (generally)corporations. Governments control the structures that are possible for corporations, which can neither be formed nor continue to exist but through acts of government; if, in any particular system, strict top-down flow of authority is essential in a corporation it is because a government has chosen to make it so. Corporations have no less "potential" for democracy than governments do.
The distinction between "pure" tyranny of corporations and the less-pure tyranny (because it was tempered by potential democracy) in government was the whole of the Chomsky quote, so its not "bickering" to point out that the tyranny of corporations cannot be any more "pure" than that of the sponsoring government.
> but the point would be the same if he had said "have a strict top-down flow of authority"
Corporations do not inherently have a strict top-down flow of authority. Labor cooperatives are still (generally)corporations. Governments control the structures that are possible for corporations, which can neither be formed nor continue to exist but through acts of government; if, in any particular system, strict top-down flow of authority is essential in a corporation it is because a government has chosen to make it so. Corporations have no less "potential" for democracy than governments do.