I imagine they take a hardline because otherwise it creates a precedent. "Can this guy come in and take photos? It's my boyfriend/brother/BFF/etc." Becomes a potential loophole.
Very unlikely to be exploited, but I imagine that's what they're thinking. If they are thinking...
Of course it creates a precedent. The question is whether such a precedent is OK. There are other examples here where that precedent happened and created a lot of good will consequently.
"We don't want to use common sense, we just want to have rules that anyone can blindly enforce."
The problem with leaving things to common sense is that different people's common sense will lead to different decisions in many situations - it can lead to questionable forms of selective enforcement.
"Other speakers' wives were allowed to attend their talks, but my homosexual life parter was escored out by security!"
"I paid $$$ to attend but this speaker brought 5 friends who got in for free!"
If you depend on common sense, you either have to make sure to hire only people who don't misjudge, ever, or have to deal with embarrassing mistakes.
Misjudgements will happen no matter what, and it's not like it's an either-or proposition. It's perfectly possible to have a set of guidelines that can be used together with common sense, but no matter what people should have the authority to _fix the problem_. The root problem in this instance wasn't using common sense to allow someone into the conference, it was a complete failure to find a satisfactory solution to the problem. Had the wife been told to wait in the meeting room, that would suck but would probably not have ended up causing a shitstorm.
And they are avoiding "embarrassing mistakes" with rigid enforcement how?
> it can lead to questionable forms of selective enforcement.
The alternative tends to lead to questionable enforcement, and it's debatable which is better.
Absolutely - I just wanted to point out that "common sense" is not a magic bullet and rigid rules are often installed for good reasons.
Companies like Microsoft know the cost of everything and the value of nothing.
You can't qualify customer support and kindness at a company like Microsoft - although I'm sure they have some USER EXPERIENCE CUSTOMER SATISFACTION ENGAGEMENT MATRIX with a catchy turn of MBA phrase somewhere.
I wouldn't have been nearly so polite if I were in his situation, and my wife would have a conniption if I were banned from watching one of her talks.
Again, I can't think of a single legitimate reason not to have let his wife go to his talk, and that simple act would have bought a lot of goodwill. The fact that no one was able to make that simple judgement call is a sign of terrible organization.