News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Embrace the desire to make money by jcnnghm on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @10:33AM (#6096373)
I recall a recent study asking millionaires if they had enough money, and most of them said something like "no, I won't feel secure until I have 10-20 mil."

That's a rational response, given that's about the minimum necessary to provide high current income ($100-200k/year), securely growing with inflation, without touching the principal. That's basically the definition of financial security. The study indicates that empirically, rich people tend to make sound financial decision, which isn't shocking.

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by resu_nimda on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @10:54AM (#6096503)
> That's basically the definition of financial security.

I feel like I'm in crazy town. What kind of definition is that? So, anyone with less than 15-20 million in the bank is financially insecure. Just like the article, which claims that "go[ing] out to expensive bars all the time in the City" is some kind of unfortunate necessity for people with high-paying jobs.

Is it just me or is there a serious lack of perspective going on here?

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by jcnnghm on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @11:13AM (#6096626)
So, anyone with less than 15-20 million in the bank is financially insecure.

Depending on your age, yes. If you are old enough you can draw down your savings, though that's a tricky game because if you live too long you run out of money. If you can't stop working and maintain a comfortable standard of living for the rest of your life, you are financially insecure.

Is it just me or is there a serious lack of perspective going on here?

There is, you should really try to figure out what you would actually need to live the rest of your life comfortably if you were unable to work. Maybe you want to live like a college student forever, in which case, you would probably need less than $10 million, but if you don't, taking 70% of your salary as an assumption, then multiplying that by 100 wouldn't be a terrible estimate.

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by npsimons on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @12:12PM (#6097007)
I'd contend that yes, techincally, "Financial Independence" (or "Fuck You" money), is a whole lot. I'd also contend that it varies, and 15-20 million would actually be towards my upper bound, personally.

There's a good book on this topic called "Your Money or Your Life" and one of the nice things they do there is focus not just on the supply side (how much money you need), but also on the demand side (by reducing what you think you need). For example, I like fine meals (like, multi-course meals upwards of $250), but I could probably go without another one for the rest of my life, or cut back. Heck, if I was retired, I could probably teach myself to make just as good food.

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by 9999 on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @11:30AM (#6096716)
If you can't stop working and maintain a comfortable standard of living for the rest of your life, you are financially insecure.

So if you are 25 years old and cannot retire today and never work a day for the rest of your life, you are financially insecure?

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by vinceguidry on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @12:16PM (#6097038)
Pretty much, yeah. Security is modeled using two terms, what you're trying to protect, and what threatens it. You're either secure against a certain threat or you're not, that's the idea.

Financial security is the model of protecting lifestyle with cash. If you're protecting your lifestyle with something else other than cash, then you don't have financial security, but you still may have security.

Basically it's very simple. If you have a big enough chunk of cash in the bank, you can generate enough income from it to secure your lifestyle. (defined in terms of expenditures) You can then use your cash to protect yourself in ways other people cannot. Cash is a cool thing to be able to use because everybody you're going to want to deal with accepts it. If instead you're using skills to protect your relationship, or even worse, a job, then you'll only be protected so long as you can derive cash from those assets.

Personally, I protect my lifestyle with my web development skills which I can take with me to any of a large number of companies who will give me cash. This affords me a great amount of security against hardship, but it isn't financial security. For one, I still have to work.

Also the world could decide that web development blows and it could suddenly be much more difficult to find a job. I would be forced to take whatever job I could find to secure my lifestyle, and then my security would only last as long as the job does.

Financial security is best because cash will (probably) never go out of style.

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by jakejake on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @12:27PM (#6097122)
People use the term "financially secure" to mean different things. You can say you're secure because you earn enough to support your current lifestyle as long as you continue to work. That is as secure as most of us get.

But you can also consider the term like this thread to mean that you are totally secure financially for life - even if you were to become unable to work.

So in you're case you may be secure for now, but you're not yet secure for life. Very few 25 year olds are already financially secure for life, though.

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by resu_nimda on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @11:35AM (#6096752)
We obviously just have different definitions of security. That nightmare scenario of having to live the rest of your life on exactly what you have now is extremely rare. There are so many people who manage to live comfortably* throughout their lives without such a massive nest egg. I don't think it makes sense to describe them as financially insecure (which to me says that they are in a bad or dangerous position) because they don't have the most extreme contingency covered.

* Note that I define this as owning a house and supporting a family without having to worry about money, not living a jet-setting life of extreme luxury or whatever.

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by swombat on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @11:02AM (#6096557)
It's certainly not a necessity, but in my experience and observations it's a strong draw.

Peer pressure, opportunity, and the pressures of the job (which makes you feel that you deserve a good time after all this hard work - work hard play hard) conspire to make it very hard not to indulge in an expensive social life when you're in a banking job.

Some people will resist that and save up anyway. Usually those who resist the pull the best are those with young children - another major financial drain.

I personally don't need £20m in the bank to feel financially secure, because I rely on my ability to earn more, and I account for that. £20m sounds about right if you want a very high likelihood of being able to retire on a perma-holiday for the rest of your life, though. I'd find that terribly tedious, myself, which is why I don't need anywhere near £20m!

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by xradionut on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @12:13PM (#6097013)
Yes.

Consider the high costs of health care, security and such. Also consider that you may want residences in different nations due to the uncertain in the political climate.

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by umsm on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @01:22PM (#6097518)
In all honesty, you may not get a chance to leave for your second home when such a situation arises.

Poor mans solution: keep in touch with family in other nations.

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by disgruntledphd2 on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @10:37AM (#6096406)
Yeah, but the reason its the hedonic treadmill is because when you ask people of any income bracket if they have enough money, they almost all say that they need 15-20% more.

It may be that you are correct in your assertions around financial security, but the notion of the hedonic treadmill is broader than that.

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by jcnnghm on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @11:06AM (#6096584)
Yeah, but the reason its the hedonic treadmill is because when you ask people of any income bracket if they have enough money, they almost all say that they need 15-20% more.

High income doesn't always imply high net worth. In 2011, fewer than 1.1% of households had over $5 million in assets. Given that at least 98.9% of households don't actually have enough money to provide moderately high current income indefinitely, everyone thinking they need 15-20% more is more of an indication of a failure in planning and basic financial literacy, not an indicator that they don't actually need more money. I think I need $10-20 million, indexed in real terms, assuming I don't step up my quality of life expectations, which is more than 20% beyond what I have today.

Think of it this way, you're walking down the street in San Francisco, and you get attacked by a hobo (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/11/naked-subway-man-vi...), which causes brain damage, leaving you unable to work in your current profession. How many years until you have to make a serious quality of life reduction?

The whole hedonic treadmill is kind of like saying that even the people with the most food today, think they will likely need more food in the future, which isn't really shocking.

Re:Embrace the desire to make money by Retric on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @12:51PM (#6097285)
If that's what your concerned about there is insurance that will cover that type of liability. As does social security.