News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by danilocampos on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:01PM (#6094244)
Apple, aspiring to be exceptional, inspires exceptional zealotry. There is much to chew on for supporters of their products and platforms.

Android aspires to ubiquity – and achieves it. And so it is polluted by handset manufacturers with inept designers and short-sighted leadership. It is beautiful – sometimes. It is mediocre – most of the time. For everything one can celebrate in Android land, there is plenty more to lament.

Because of this, Android doesn't need a Gruber – it needs an anti-Gruber.

A churlish character who, rather than celebrating the excellent, laments the shabby. An irascible voice to scold the masses who value the wrong things. While Gruber is enamored of one party and frustrated by the rest, our Anti-Gruber must be frustrated by all. Annoyed by Apple's approach. Annoyed by the squandered opportunities of his own camp.

If you ever read the work of Ted Dziuba, that'll help you capture the sort of voice I'm imagining. "Jesus Christ Silicon Valley" is a bit over the top, but probably lives in a similar neighborhood:

http://jesuschristsiliconvalley.tumblr.com

This character must be pissed off for reasons, he must elucidate them consistently, and must be relentless in the coverage of his ire. Curmudgeonry is entertaining when it's purposeful – especially when it also serves to educate. Android enthusiasts would link to such blog – some because of its skewering of their preferred platform, others because of their agreement with the presented frustrations. Apple enthusiasts would link because sometimes it agreed with their worldview.

There's room for this character.

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by voltagex_ on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:20PM (#6094311)
I am. I'm bloody angry that consumers prioritize tiny/thin phones over a battery that lasts all day.

I hate how Google handles their bug reports.

I hate how low latency audio still isn't a priority on Android. I hate how the bluetooth stack was broken seemingly for no reason at all.

I hate that there's still no Bluetooth LE support. I hate how Google won't let the Commonwealth Bank of Australia implement a Google-wallet style application.

I hate how half the Android OEMs can't be arsed releasing proper sourcecode.

But I think the Nexus 4 is one of the best devices I own...

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by omonra on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @09:14AM (#6095956)
For your #1 - I use a zero lemon battery with my S3. Lasts 2 days of VERY heavy usage - http://www.zerolemon.com/.

That's the best part about Android - you choose whether you want to have a thin phone or one that lasts a long time.

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by statictype on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:25PM (#6094333)
I find your ideas fascinating and would like to subscribe to your newsletter.

So please make one.

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by voltagex_ on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:40PM (#6094402)
Hey thanks. I've been procrastinating while trying to start a blog for ages.

Do you think I'd have to stick to just Android? I've been meaning to make a post (or several) out of [1] this comment.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6037640

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by eco on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:47PM (#6094429)
> I hate that there's still no Bluetooth LE support.

I believe tomorrow's expected 4.3 announcement adds Bluetooth LE (and all around improved Bluetooth).

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by voltagex_ on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @02:15AM (#6094741)
Woohoo! Nexus 4 pays off.
Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by danilocampos on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:21PM (#6094321)
If you can channel that frustration into entertainment and education, you, too, can sell outrageously lucrative feed sponsorships.
Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by voltagex_ on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:37PM (#6094385)
Maybe I'll just stick with Gittip.
Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by recuter on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:21PM (#6094323)
When the iPhone was introduced in 2007, Steve boasted that it is 5 years ahead of the competition. It wasn't hyperbole.

Ever since, the jailbreakers and Android tinkerers have provided a fertile testing ground for half baked ideas. Apple kept iterating, filling the gaps, and adopting the best things poorly done by the aforementioned to boot.

It is 2013 -- I can't even think of a good reason to jailbreak anymore. The low hanging fruit are gone and there's not much left to be OCD about. There's no room for this character, this stuff is now officially boring. It comes down to the old choice between running OS X or some Linux distro.

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by skeletonjelly on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @12:07AM (#6094469)
> It is 2013 -- I can't even think of a good reason to jailbreak anymore. The low hanging fruit are gone and there's not much left to be OCD about

What about removing that bookshelf icon permanently? Customising the UI? These are all visual things people who subscribe to self-diagnised OCD obsess with.

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by recuter on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @12:17AM (#6094495)
You can remove the bookshelf icon in iOS 7. :)

Fiddling with the UI style is like going through all the various window managers and desktop environments for Linux with the significant difference that there's really no chance at any productivity wins whatsoever when it comes to the smartphone form factor.

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by skeletonjelly on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @12:59AM (#6094594)
Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by ok_craig on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:22PM (#6094324)
Gruber already does lament the shabby doesn't he? So what'd be the difference? In addition to calling out Google / Microsoft / Samsung, he also calls out Apple? Doesn't really seem like a big diff, except maybe for being slightly more objective.
Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by danilocampos on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:26PM (#6094335)
> So what'd be the difference?

I think the big difference would be hating everyone equally. Gruber laments the shabby with a song in his heart and a spring in his step because Steve Jobs was brilliant, Jony Ive satisfies and Stanley Kubrick was a master filmmaker.

This guy? "Fuck everyone, that's why." That's his schtick. So on the odd days when the sun comes out, you pay very close attention. The rest of the time, wry smiles.

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by pohl on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @07:48AM (#6095573)
Designing a hypothetical persons's schtick ahead of time will never work. It would only be sustainable if it's genuine.

If not genuine, something would have to motivate them to — every day for over a decade — wake up, make fussy coffee and sit down at their clicky keyboard to produce something in character.

I don't think this character idea is fertile enough to inspire a Colbert.

Re:Where is the Android John Gruber? by BadassFractal on Wednesday July 24, 2013 @01:30AM (#6094659)
Love that blog, thank you for the share.