Re:Ask HN: Should equity be traded for advice and connections?
by brudgers on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @10:30PM
(#6094161)
It sounds like a bunch of crap to me.
The list of what they will do makes up for its lack of milestones with an over abundance of waffle words prefacing so-vague-as-to-be-meaningless actions - e.g.
Connect Company with prospective beta customers
Forget, how many, forget when, that's not closing sales. Here's the base analysis:
If you don't need cash from investment right now, then none of what they are offering, even when viewed in the most favorable light possible, adds value to your company - you don't need positioning or critique or a grant.
On the other hand, if you need cash now, then you don't need and investment banker and VC who aren't writing you a check in exchange for equity - and granting them equity just makes raising capital more complex because now the vultures have legal standing within your corporate structure.
My gut tells me that their big idea is to get equity for no cash, sit back and hope that things take off more or less on their own. They're not even committed to attending meetings:
When reasonably available, attend investor, strategic
partner, beta customer, and other such strategic
meetings.
If they don't, they have lost very little. If they do, they have enough leverage to perhaps take control, or make their taking control the least painful alternative.
The list of what they will do makes up for its lack of milestones with an over abundance of waffle words prefacing so-vague-as-to-be-meaningless actions - e.g.
Forget, how many, forget when, that's not closing sales. Here's the base analysis:If you don't need cash from investment right now, then none of what they are offering, even when viewed in the most favorable light possible, adds value to your company - you don't need positioning or critique or a grant.
On the other hand, if you need cash now, then you don't need and investment banker and VC who aren't writing you a check in exchange for equity - and granting them equity just makes raising capital more complex because now the vultures have legal standing within your corporate structure.
My gut tells me that their big idea is to get equity for no cash, sit back and hope that things take off more or less on their own. They're not even committed to attending meetings:
If they don't, they have lost very little. If they do, they have enough leverage to perhaps take control, or make their taking control the least painful alternative.Good luck.