Ask PG: Leader board ranked my comment karma
I think comment karma is a much more accurate way of representing the quality of contributions a particular user makes. And I don't think factoring in submission karma really adds any significant value to assessing that quality. A lot more thought is put into sparking interesting conversation than submitting an interesting article, but often times, the karma doesn't quite reflect that, as submissions can get voted up to relatively high amounts, making any comment karma gain seem insignificant, and recognizing/rewarding users inaccurately.
So, an alternate leader board would be appreciated.
(
11 comments
| 10 points
| on HN
)
Your list may be better if it is bigger or if it lists only the users who have made more than a certain number of comments.
If not, can you delete my account?
I doubt that anyone has ever gotten 80 karma points from writing a single comment, but it is difficult to use comments alone as a ranking system since there are a lot of people who just read articles and will ignore any additional commentary.
(And also, users who self-submit their own blog posts do deserve the karma.)