Yes, you can make a lot of money buying and selling stocks, but what is HFT actually contributing to the economy other than paying HR costs for its employees?
Market efficiency relies on extreme competition between investors that are highly intelligent and able to make quick decisions. When you can sum up much of those decisions in algorithms, what better way to deliver competition than HFT?
Opponents argue markets were efficient enough pre-HFT and that any benefits delivered by HFT are more 'academic' than practical. Opponents also argue that the level of uncertainty ("inexperience") with HFT brings more risks than argued benefits, as well as all of the "usual" criticisms of 'trading' vs. 'investing'.
As you may be able to tell, I myself am sitting on the fence on this issue, albeit with both feet pointing towards the opponents' side.
I'll try and illustrate with a contrived example. Say i want to buy 1000 shares at no more than $1 each. By using HFT, a trading firm can put together the order 'package' by combining many smaller trades at varying prices such that the average price comes out at the lowest (or target) price.
The competitive edge for a trading firm comes from being able to consistently fulfill orders, meaning they get more orders / customers.
Does that kind of explain the utility of HFT? Yes it allows a trading firm to make more money, but they way they do that is by providing a better service - not by simply exeucting a huge volume of trades and making fractions of a cent from each one.
Either way, it doesn't seem to be about actually funding companies. Maybe stock trades can help influence companies to change strategies or leaders, but I don't see the point of doing it in a forum from which the companies will never see the investment.
I don't think I understand the stock market as being anything more than a gambling game for people with a ton of money. Not sure what the IPOs of Facebook, Groupon, or Zynga did for anyone other than top execs who were already making a ton of cash per year, or the traders who bought and sold options.
In practice, it's probably fairly neutral, so long as no-one is playing silly b@#$%^rs, front-running other people's trades or similar.
I don't claim to understand it completely, but that's the justification I've heard before.
1: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/news/8753784/The-300m-...