News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by ams6110 on Monday July 22, 2013 @04:55PM (#6086409)
I found the comparison of the iPhone to a "Star Trek" communicator a bit off topic. Even 40 years ago, I don't think anyone would have argued that something like an iPhone would be possible in the future. The idea didn't violate any known physics. Hand-held two-way radios were already commonplace. The fact that we achieved sufficient advances in circuit miniaturization and battery technology to build a hand-held smartphone does not in any way imply that we'll be able to build a warp drive for a spacecraft.
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by dclowd9901 on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:09PM (#6086473)
How about 60 years ago? 80? 100? At some point, if I explained to someone that I would be able to pick up a small black plate filled with electrical signals (ha!) flying around it many million times per second and use it to learn the answer to any question, talk to (AND SEE) any person in the world, in real time, how far back would you have to go to hear "that's impossible," because I guarantee you, at some point, someone thought that it was, even if not 40 years ago.

Hell, I remember explaining to my dad when I was a kid that someday there would be a way to watch whatever you wanted, whenever you wanted, simply because that's what people wanted to exist. In my mind, it was an inevitability, and he felt it would never happen. This was only a scant 20 or so years ago.

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by lmm on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @10:46AM (#6090320)
>At some point, if I explained to someone that I would be able to pick up a small black plate filled with electrical signals (ha!) flying around it many million times per second and use it to learn the answer to any question, talk to (AND SEE) any person in the world, in real time, how far back would you have to go to hear "that's impossible," because I guarantee you, at some point, someone thought that it was, even if not 40 years ago.

As soon as we have real science (i.e. post-Descartes) anything mechanistic seems possible. There was probably a point at which we had insufficient knowledge to say one way or another, but this isn't the kind of thing that's ruled out by physical law in the way that FTL travel is.

>Hell, I remember explaining to my dad when I was a kid that someday there would be a way to watch whatever you wanted, whenever you wanted, simply because that's what people wanted to exist. In my mind, it was an inevitability, and he felt it would never happen. This was only a scant 20 or so years ago.

You were lucky that time, but it's not a reliable heuristic. Plenty of people want to be immortal, but it hasn't happened yet. (OTOH, human immortality seems a lot more plausible than FTL travel - we can't see how it would work yet, but there's no law that rules it out - which puts it in the same category I think a phone would have seemed like in Newton's day).

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by bitwize on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:41PM (#6086948)
* How about 60 years ago? 80? 100? At some point, if I explained to someone that I would be able to pick up a small black plate filled with electrical signals (ha!) flying around it many million times per second and use it to learn the answer to any question, talk to (AND SEE) any person in the world, in real time, how far back would you have to go to hear "that's impossible," because I guarantee you, at some point, someone thought that it was, even if not 40 years ago.*

Pretty far back. Even Dick Tracy had a similar thing.

I think you would have to go back before Marconi and Tesla.

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by VladRussian2 on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:23PM (#6086547)
>The idea didn't violate any known physics.

the idea that space expansion generates effect that looks like FTL in fixed space model doesn't violate any known physics - just look at the highly red-shifted galaxies.

>The fact that we achieved sufficient advances in circuit miniaturization and battery technology to build a hand-held smartphone does not in any way imply that we'll be able to build a warp drive for a spacecraft.

we just need sufficiently advance (increase) energy production and learn to focus it so that the density in a given volume will reach the "mass density of black hole multiplied by c-square" - that will be a good start to manage the shape of the spacetime

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @08:21AM (#6089512)
Actually, to argue the other side, "We have no evidence it's physically impossible" has never been a very good argument that anything will actually work.

Actually, hard scifi is loaded with stuff that falls under the category of "We can't yet prove it's physically impossible, but neither has anyone actually proposed viable non-crank theories on how it really works."