News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In America, Where You're Born Is Correlated With How Far ... by rayiner on Monday July 22, 2013 @11:29AM (#6084311)
What's a concrete example of (4) in this context that doesn't reduce trivially to (3)?
Re:In America, Where You're Born Is Correlated With How Far ... by thaumasiotes on Monday July 22, 2013 @12:00PM (#6084555)
Well, I can't actually produce a number for this, but how would you feel about a correlation between first digit of US zip code and incidence of Tay-Sachs disease?

Note: Tay-Sachs is something that happens to Jews, and Jews are concentrated in New York.

Does the zip code connection satisfy your demand of "in this context"?

Re:In America, Where You're Born Is Correlated With How Far ... by rayiner on Monday July 22, 2013 @12:09PM (#6084620)
My point is that "where you were born" is a broader term than "the zip code where you were born." Obviously your zip code doesn't cause anything. But your zip code determines things like what the schools are like in the area, what the income demographics are like in the area, etc. When people say "where you were born determines where you end up" they're referring to that larger definition of "where you were born" not literally your zip code. That's what makes many versions of (4) collapse into (3).

Though I think your Tay-Sachs example is one that arguably does not.

Re:In America, Where You're Born Is Correlated With How Far ... by GeneralMayhem on Monday July 22, 2013 @11:44AM (#6084445)
Both are caused by good parenting.
Re:In America, Where You're Born Is Correlated With How Far ... by rayiner on Monday July 22, 2013 @11:57AM (#6084535)
Good parenting causes you to be born outside the southeast?
Re:In America, Where You're Born Is Correlated With How Far ... by kenj0418 on Monday July 22, 2013 @01:52PM (#6085291)
Well, I thank my mother all the time for moving north several years before I was born.

But I'm pretty sure the comment was referring to "Children in homes containing books display intelligence at elevated rates" not the overall article.