News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI announces review of 2,000 cases featuring hair samples by DannyBee on Monday July 22, 2013 @02:19AM (#6082103)
First, I mainly care about the jury nullification part.

The rest is essentially you suggesting that you can manufacture non-reliable evidence and introduce it.

The problem with this is that the evidence must have probative value, and generally be reliable, to be admitted.

" Do you really think a judge could prevent you from arguing that it's not your handwriting without creating grounds for an appeal?"

If your intent is to corrupt, confuse, or otherwise mislead a jury, yes, i think a judge will prevent you.

Even if he doesn't prevent you, he will strongly admonish the jury about it, and if another juror believes a given juror is not following instructions, they are likely to report them, and it will get dealt with.

This happens all the time.

As for grounds for appeal, generally, evidence rulings are reviewed for abuse of discretion. Basically, the appellate court must find that the decision was wholly unsupported by the evidence, illegal, or clearly incorrect. Even then, it is likely to be found to be harmless error anyway, unless this is the only evidence.

Of course, you are welcome to believe what you want, what do I know.

Re:FBI announces review of 2,000 cases featuring hair samples by belorn on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:26PM (#6086877)
While I don't dispute your analyzes of the legal system, it do paint a rather grim picture. Evidence in this case can then only ever be used in one direction.

Had the handwriting and name been that of the suspect, it would without doubt be used as evidence to crucify the suspect. However, if the handwriting and name is about someone else, then the evidence is regarded as confusing and thus discarded.

It looks to me as a realistic, maybe a bit cynical view of the legal system. Is this really how empirical evidence should be used?

Re:FBI announces review of 2,000 cases featuring hair samples by Alex3917 on Monday July 22, 2013 @11:26PM (#6088063)
> The rest is essentially you suggesting that you can manufacture non-reliable evidence and introduce it.

I have no doubt that a judge can and would block the evidence if they thought the intent was to 'corrupt, confuse, or otherwise mislead.' What I do doubt is that the judge would automatically think that this was doing that.

E.g. how is this any different from "If the glove don't fit, you must acquit?"