The issue here is that the Linux kernel developers are starting to make decisions that assume systemd is being used. For example, the (proposed?) new cgroups API is being built with the idea that systemd will manage it, and anything else that wants to interact with it will go through systemd.
> Unprivileged access to the cgroup hierarchy will be strongly discouraged; the hope is to have a single, privileged process handling all of the cgroup management tasks. That process will, in turn, provide some sort of higher-level interface to the rest of the system.
and that:
> This hierarchy becomes private property of systemd. systemd will set it up. Systemd will maintain it. Systemd will rearrange it. Other software that wants to make use of cgroups can do so only through systemd's APIs.
That is, systemd will implement a manager on top of the new cgroups API, and all cgroups users will be assumed to go through systemd.
True, except that the systemd developers are in charge of defining this API and have no reason to consult with other cgroups manager developers when defining it. This is, to make an analogy, equivalent to allowing Microsoft to unilaterally define all web standards from now on. The competitors are always going to be playing catch-up, and there's going to be tons of edge cases where the competitors don't quite work the same.
- Certain guarantees and consistencies disappear. Instead of having a system that you know you can rely on, it suddenly becomes entirely dependent on the configuration options. While it sounds nice if any part can be enabled, disabled, moved or swapped, then the system's predictability goes down. Furthermore, some combinations may be incompatible because abstractions are inherently leaky. Good luck finding out whether you're suffering from a compatibility problem or not. You can compare this to the many complaints about Android fragmentation. Because everybody can customize Android, writing an app that works on all Android devices becomes extremely difficult.
- Installation complexity goes way up. It's much easier to install a system if it states "I need this, this and this", instead of "I can use this, or this, or this, if it's configured in X, Y and Z way".
- Certain features cannot be implemented in a simple manner because you have to cater to the lowest common denominator. XFree86 was like that. Because it had to be portable, it cannot assume any kernel capabilities. And as a result XFree86 came with its own mode setting code, its own ELF binary loader, had to run as root, etc etc.