It seems odd to me that so many Americans seem pessimistic about their own government. I could understand if the attitude was, "We could make universal, socialized healthcare work. We could make it cheaper than Canada's. We could make it better than Sweden's. We just don't want to for ideological reasons."
But how can it be that the attitude is, "It would never work here?" You're the greatest empire in the history of civilization. What is this word "can't" and why is it in your vocabulary?
The problem is the morass of laws we've accumulated around healthcare over the years for various reasons that now interact in complex ways that nobody foresaw. Like the law designed to make Medicare or Medicaid (I forget which) drugs cheaper that ended up making it illegal to give free birth control to college students.
We also have the laws from when people believed that competition increased costs and so tried to ban competition between hospitals. Or the committee that sets doctor's reimbursement rates for Medicare procedures based on the *$%@# labor theory of value. And the laws designed to prevent people from overcharging Medicare that means that everybody has to worry about those rates across the industry. Or the way that the makeup of that committee means that primary care physicians gets shafted.
And the fact that we allow so few schools to teach medicine means that they can charge an arm and a leg, which means that those poor shafted PCPs need the kickbacks they get for assigning specialist care in order to pay off their student loans and malpractice insurance.
And I could go on.
And now we have this system that's incomprehensibly complex. So Congress has no way of figuring how to fix it on their own. There are people who've spent years figuring out how all of this works, but that's their job and if the system was actually fixed their job would be gone and that understanding they spent years acquiring would be useless.
Which isn't to say that this is entirely hopeless. There have been some efforts at the hospital level like Kaiser Permanente's to ameliorate the perverse incentives in the system and capture some of the value unlocked by that. And there are some laws that could be changes or repealed (like the one against hospital competition) without really breaking anything. So I think that gradual reform might be possible, but it's going to be a long road that doesn't particularly involve the issues that people tend to talk about around healthcare.
Maybe it would be "lower quality", but least it would offer choice for many , and be a great research lab for low cost healthcare.
To an extent I wonder how much of that is due to lack of recent experience with starting from scratch. The United States hasn't had a revolution, a war on its territory, or a regime collapse in a long time.
It's not just that many Americans have been persuaded that a single-payer system works for the old and disabled, but for some reason isn't right for everyone else. Rather, many Americans have been brainwashed into simultaneously supporting Medicare and opposing a generalized single-payer system, with equal fervor, without noticing the contradiction.
(Yes, really. I saw a photo a year or two ago of a protester at a rally carrying a sign that said "NO SOCIALIZED MEDICINE / DON'T TOUCH OUR MEDICARE", or similar language.)
Knowing this, if one really wanted to implement single payer care in America, it would be more likely to succeed if the program was marketed as something like "Super Patriot America Care, just like our boys get in the US Military!" rather than calling it single payer care, which is some Euro/Canada not-invented-here thing that can't possibly ever work, because of America.
From what I understand, drugs are much cheaper in Canada. Almost all medical procedures are cheaper here. I met a couple from Texas who flew up here for something, and they said it was cheaper for them buy plane tickets, stay here in a hotel for two weeks, and all other travel expenses, and get the procedure done here than to do it at home (uninsured). They still saved thousands of dollars after all that. That's craziness.
Maybe there's no perfect system. But the United States spends the most on health care per citizen, and has the lowest percent of government support. [1] You should at least consider what others are successfully doing to get the costs down and increase the quality of care for the uninsured and poor.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_compared#Internatio...
Local solutions don't really work for medical care, in terms of the legalities and economic structure, you have to require everyone to participate.
In this case, size and diversity work against us, it's just a lot easier in a small homogenous Scandinavian country.
Anyway, we have Obamacare gradually being implemented, where all employers above a certain size are supposed to offer insurance, and everyone else is supposed to buy it (the 'mandate' which the Supreme Court says is really just a tax).
So, maybe a minimum level of health care will start to be universal. But in order to get it through they made sure everyone was well greased. If the doctors, the hospitals, the insurance companies, or the pharmaceutical companies had to tighten belts a notch that would have been enough to sink it. So, it's going to stay very expensive.
I really think that people don't appreciate this fully for a lot of problems that the US has which have been 'solved' in other countries -- usually smaller European ones. Mail delivery, rail transportation, healthcare, etc. The US has a very unique blend of very urban and very rural areas that makes it hard to scale lots of services easily to everybody.
You see it in million places: The limited number of medical schools, The lack of nurse practitioners doing the simple routine jobs in most specialties(dental, family, colonoscopy, anesthsia. Many others could exist), The lack of automation and expert systems[4] and automated patient interview[3] tools, the fact that family practitioners could replace a lot of the specialists work at lower costs[1], Many medical jobs could be done with a lot less training[2], the lack of use of proven processes like checklists[5], etc.
All those changes could save a lot of money, and raise quality. We know what to do, But how do we implement it ?
[1]http://www.rwjf.org/en/grants/grantees/project-echo.html
[2]Because there's a brain drain in africa to the west, some countries have started a 3 year surgeon degree program. Doctors who finished this degree seem to have equivalent results to fully trained doctors in simple/medium complexity surgeries.
[3]Research showed doctors only ask about half of the questions needed in a typical visit. Automated interview systems could at least gather more complete data.
[4]There's research review showing that correct implementation of decision support/expert systems could improve results.
[5]Peter provonost showed that checklists could reduce infection rates in one procedure from 8/12 percent to zero.This was around 10 years ago. I think gawande showed similar results in other stuff. checklists are still not commonly used.
When I have challenged doctors about this, they tend to say "Ah, but you're focused on data, we focus on diagnosing the patient", which is basically gibberish.
That web app can name any person you think of by asking 20 or so questions. Just imagine what you could do if you made that but for diseases.
Since the US doesn't annex territories for itself and keep them as colonies as part of some Commonwealth Realm.
Although the US could have if it tried, with the slightest flex of a myoblast, in the last great war. It still can.
Pretty sure that's what he/she meant.
Nope. Neve happens. (Cough >Hawai'i<, cough)
(And yes Scotland has an upcoming referendum in 2014 on the issue of independence from the UK.[1] This is widely believed to be a losing proposition.)
Commonwealth Realm Antigua and Barbuda, Australia, Bahamas, Barbados, Belize, Canada, Grenada, Jamaica, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Solomon Islands, Tuvalu
Crown dependencies: Guernsey, Jersey, Isle of Man
British Overseas Territories: Akrotiri and Dhekelia, Anguilla, Bermuda, British Antarctic Territory, British Indian Ocean Territory, British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands, Falkland Islands, Gibraltar, Montserrat, Pitcairn Islands, Saint Helena, Ascension and Tristan da Cunha, South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands, Turks and Caicos Islands
[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottish_independence_referendu...
Perhaps what the Scottish people don't like the idea of is the SNP becoming the governing party of Scotland. However, and this is frequently ignored by the unionist press in Scotland, the SNP would not necessarily be the ruling party. There would be a new general election to vote for a new Scottish government in an independent Scotland and that could be Labour, SNP, Tory, Democrat, Greens or whatever.
There is a huge amount of disinformation banded about by Cameron, Osborne and other unionist politicians about Scotland's capabilities.
One note on efficiency - something like 30% (yes yes, citation needed) of American health dollars go towards insurance administration. A family member of mine works in Canadian health care and had a recent arrival (a physician, IIRC) from the States ask where the "billing floor" was because an out-of-country patient needed some sort of paperwork done. Well, Canadian hospitals don't have floors dedicated to processing payment. There was a small office.
On a second note, having your healthcare connected to your employment situation seems like insanity - I can't fathom anything that would argue in favour of that, unless you're an employer looking for additional leverage over your serfs.
It really is, although I don't think people realize it until you say it out loud. Precisely when you can least afford paying for a medical emergency -- when you're unemployed and thus have no income -- is precisely when it's most expensive. How broken is that? It would be insane in any other industry to charge your customer significantly more for the exact same service, simply because they're using a different payment method. Not to mention the horrible situation that arises if you acquire a medical condition so debilitating -- which usually also means it's expensive -- that it prevents you from working.
Which is not to say there is a perfect solution. But just about any of the alternatives would be better than the US system.
The fact of the matter is that we've somehow managed to end up with a set-up that has just the bad parts from both models. All the runaway costs of regulatory capture, and all of the gross inefficiency of entrenched bureaucracy.
I could have told them that.
I designed and implemented portable electronic medical records for 5 regional exchanges. Hospitals, clinics, pharmacies, ambulances, permanent stays (nursing homes), insurers, labs, etc.
Coordination was tough, because everyone thinks they own the data (and loathe to share) and are often competitors.
It's all about the incentives. The only fix I can think of is single payer, which will compel everyone to play nicely together.
That said...
Simply having the state by state insurance comparison portals seems to be very effective for price competition, better than I could have predicted. So on balance, it looks like the impact of Obamacare / ACA will be really good, if not perfect.
As of February, it was about $130 billion off over 10 years (i.e. $1.3 trillion vs. $1.17 trillion). That is not 'severalfold'.
http://www.californiahealthline.org/articles/2013/2/6/cbo-up...
And insurance premiums on ACA exchanges are coming in 20% lower than expected:
http://aspe.hhs.gov/health/reports/2013/MarketCompetitionPre...
I do agree Republicans believe this thing is going to fail and are trying hard to encourage that.
I can't easily find a citation for it right now though. But http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-250_162-57589988/smooth-on-time-... confirms that at this point the rollout is facing potential trouble and needs billions more.
I have heard some republican state governors are pushing exchange setup to the Feds as part of their "gum it up" strategy, which may be pushing setup costs up. That said, as strange as it is to say, 5 billion is a relatively small number for the US government or the US economy.
They're still attacking Roe vs. Wade, after all.
It would be political poison, especially given the rollout will have had a few years to cement by March 2017 (the earliest anything could be taken to floor). Hard to tell what public opinion will be like in 3.5 years, but I'd wager it will be net-positive on ACA.
Is it mandatory insurance? Insurance doesn't make everything affordable, but it probably wild have been helpful. Though maybe the co-pay would have been $50k.
Universal tax-payer funded insurance? The term "tax payer" is interesting because politicians and pundits forget that we're all tax payers in one form or another. Granted some pay more, some are net consumers of govt services. But tax payers mean us, and those with more earned income more than those with less. I think the main difference between taxes and donation is choice.
Single-payer or government provided healthcare? Pretty sure that no one would identify the government as the picture perfect example of efficiency. Plus, putting elected officials or their appointees in charge of handing out goods and services doesnt seem to be sustainable. Not that putting profit seeking entities in charge has yielded the ideal result.
Making drug providers, healthcare providers and everyone else in that supply chain non-profit? Profit has enormous motivational powers. Not always for good. But it is pretty amazing what can be accomplished by organizations setup to create wealth.
Big Data? Sorry, I couldn't resist. Well, lets use that as a proxy for innovation. It would seem that greater opportunity for innovation would help. Lower barriers to trying new drugs, procedures, diet, treatments would allow for potentially lower cost solutions to be created.
Separating health care from your job? Of your insurer only needs you to be healthy until you find a new job, there's not much in incentive for long-term healthcare and preventative screenings to identify tumors and other problems before they become an expensive problem. Though that would seem to be an arguement in favor of a single payer system.
Sorry, I don't have an answer. Hopefully, great stories like the OP continue. But if we don't make it scale then we haven't really done all we possibly can do.