Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say
by lonnyk on Friday July 19, 2013 @05:42PM
(#6073143)
Is it more accurate to say that the Supreme Court interpreted the law and the law makes this acceptable?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say
by btilly on Friday July 19, 2013 @05:49PM
(#6073189)
By my non-lawyerly understanding, no. The question of when standing to sue exists is a question of common law, not statutory law.
Had they decided that standing exists, then they would have had opportunity to rule on the law itself.
Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say
by dragonwriter on Friday July 19, 2013 @05:58PM
(#6073236)
> The question of when standing to sue exists is a question of common law, not statutory law.
Standing has both Constitutional elements and prudential elements (the latter could be referred to as "common law"); the actual injury element is Constitutional, but the prohibition on generalized rather than particular injury is prudential.
Here, a particularized injury is raised but the problem is that the injury is speculative rather than actual, so the problem would be with Constitutional requirements for standing, not the prudential elements.