News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by dmix on Friday July 19, 2013 @05:36PM (#6073100)
The government deciding what is and what is not constitutional?

What could go wrong.

Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by anigbrowl on Friday July 19, 2013 @05:37PM (#6073106)
The government isn't deciding it. It's asserting its position. To a judge, who will make the actual decision.
Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by dmix on Friday July 19, 2013 @06:22PM (#6073351)
As long as what's being challenged as unconstitutional in court is protected as a state secret, that sadly isn't the case.
Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by anigbrowl on Friday July 19, 2013 @07:02PM (#6073507)
Yes it is. Adding adjectives to your argument doesn't make it more persuasive.
Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by dmix on Friday July 19, 2013 @10:26PM (#6074094)
State secrets completely undermine the concept of judicial checks on government power. This isn't a new idea, it's been heavily criticized since Bush has been in power and expanded the use of it:

> Glenn Greenwald alleges that the Bush administration attempted to expand executive power, as evidenced by the unitary executive theory propagated by John Yoo. The theory suggests that the President, as Commander-in-Chief, cannot be bound by Congress or any law, national or international. By invoking the state secrets privilege in cases involving actions taken in the war on terror (i.e. extraordinary rendition, allegations of torture, allegedly violating the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act) Greenwald opines the administration tried to evade judicial review of these claims of exceptional war powers. In effect, this is preventing a judicial ruling determining whether there is a legal basis for such expansive executive power. With that in mind, applying this privilege makes impeachment the only possible means left for Congress to exercise their duty to uphold the checks and balances constitutionally intended to prevent abuse of power.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_secrets_privilege

Since impeachment is a highly unlikely scenario... if a government action is unconstitutional and citizens have a no way of challenging the constitutionality in court due to the government deeming it's actions were a secret, then how is the government not deciding what is considered constitutional or not?

Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by jessaustin on Friday July 19, 2013 @08:10PM (#6073733)
The fact that the state secrets argument was overruled a couple of times in the mists of history before most of us were born doesn't mean any court would overrule it today.
Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by alan_cx on Friday July 19, 2013 @06:23PM (#6073362)
Who appoints the judges?

Wouldn't be the government, would it?

Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by anigbrowl on Friday July 19, 2013 @07:05PM (#6073518)
No, it wouldn't. It's an administration, one temporary occupant of a government role. Federal judges serve for life so that they are not beholden to any other part of government once appointed, and even you will have to admit that federal judges frequently rule against the government.

I'm getting tired of your trite anarchism; according to your profile you're here for the 'grown up comments' and I wish you try making some instead of always going for the cheap shot.

Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by GhotiFish on Friday July 19, 2013 @09:14PM (#6073910)
You know. I looked at the comment history expecting trite anarchism.

It didn't come off as trite to me (or very anarchic).

I'm gonna have to disagree with you here in general, but the parent post was trite. Yes it was.

Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by dmix on Saturday July 20, 2013 @12:04AM (#6074301)
My comment was admittedly hyperbolic, so I'll provide an expanded reply. Yes, the government doesn't have the ability to deem what is constitutional in every situation, but as long as it's under the umbrella of national security, the safeguards of judicial checks on power are crippled.

State secrets have been used as a defense in courts more times in the last decade than the 50 years before 2001.

There are countless situations where the Bush and Obama administration have acted without traditional judicial oversight with seemingly legal proceedings justified by national security (see CIA secret prison network).

The supreme court has even ruled so on many occasions against the government. But those cases are quite rare compared to the frequency of which the government acts under the safeguard of secrecy. Very few people (probably >99.9%) ever challenge the governments claim to secrecy (for example NSLs). Even mega-corporations are fearful, let alone citizens. So the question of the efficacy of judicial oversight regarding the constitutional limitations imposed on the government is a very challenging one to even measure.

> The court, encouraged by the government, has thus created at Catch -22: only the government knows who it is wiretapping without a warrant; so long as it claims that information is a “state secret”, no one will have standing to sue and the government can never be held accountable for breaking the law.

http://washingtonindependent.com/31800/does-national-securit...

The concept of state secrecy is quite brilliant in it's ability to limit legal challenge. Therefore leading to the states ability to say any action conducted in secret is "constitutional", because it can't be proven otherwise in court (unless a radical judge ignores the state secret clause which has happened only in extremely rare situations).

Re:NSA Phone Snooping Cannot Be Challenged in Court, Feds Say by alan_cx on Saturday July 20, 2013 @11:00AM (#6075389)
I would reply, but I don't care for the insults from some one with your karma weight. I'll probably run in to problems replying.

Just know that I wouldn't insult you in the same way you have me.