Re:Biggest Virus Yet Found, May Be Fourth Domain of Life?
by CreRecombinase on Friday July 19, 2013 @04:40PM
(#6072830)
My undergraduate senior project was on the interaction between breast milk and microbial ecology in infants, so I can appreciate the difficulty of protein phylogenetics in non eukaryotic organisms. I think it's still important to underscore that simply because whatever tree I get phylip to spit out doesn't reflect the true evolotionary history of the organism/gene/whatever, doesn't mean that 1)tracing the evolutionary history of an organism/gene/whatever is "bullshit" (whatever you mean by that) or that 2)the evolutionary history cannot be elucidated by other means. Phylogenetics can be used to discover gene fusion events and convergent evolution.
the hydrogenase that I work with is part of a mobile element; it's found in our organism in a gene island, but also straight up in the genome of another organism that was isolated 5000 kilometers away, in a totally different ecotype. both of these guys are found in the ocean, but none of the other members in the broad family that it comes from are oceanic: they come from terrestrial volcanic mats.
So obviously species-wise discrete or fuzzy taxa do not work for me; but even protein phylogenetics can be muddied by things like random gene fusions and convergent evolution. I'm not sure that some of the trees that I generate are actually taxonomic, but may be the result of selective pressure against a highly conserved scaffold.
Of course, they're still useful, even if they're bullshit... Because I don't care about phylogenetics, I care about function. If the tree that I make is an unfaithful representation of the historical record, no big deal, as long as it faitfully clusters function.