Because belief isn't all-or-nothing.
> That's not what you're saying, however.
Yes, it is exactly what I'm saying.
Why not?
> Yes, it is exactly what I'm saying.
Here, let me save us a few rounds:
No it's not.
Yes it is.
No it's not.
Yes it is.
No it's not.
Now how about you rephrase what you wrote so we can move forward?
> Why not?
There a point that can be reached in a discussion where you realize that (assuming the other participant is honest, without which there are other insurmountable problems) you just don't have the requisite common understanding of reality to have a fruitful discussion.
The point at which you question the idea that belief, in general, isn't necessarily absolute is that point, for me, in this discussion.
I agree. It is at this point when I cannot continue a discussion. Have a good day.
Meanwhile, we might all do well to read and reflect on http://lesswrong.com/lw/kg/expecting_short_inferential_dista...
Why?
> These are obviously very different beliefs.
Then make them both "the most effective means", if that makes it easier to understand.
> Saying that I think the logic of your argument is invalid is not saying I believe the statement it was offered to support is negative.
That's not what you're saying, however.