If he had a way to do one-way broadcasts, like over the radio, where any snoopers could not discover the receivers then it would make more sense to do a positive control system. But there really isn't a mechanism for that on the internet. Even if he posted to usenet, given enough time, a sufficiently motivated nation-state adversary could probably trace through enough usenet servers to figure out what clients were looking for those reset messages.
Maybe a packed Tor client + desktop application that does every action it needs to do for the user, if the master hasn't changed the server variable or if it's not accessible for [insert random number] days, weeks or years.
[edited for clarity]
Therefore the version that he did is safer for him.
It should also be noted that an active dead man's switch opens the possibility that surveillance of Snowden will establish the mechanism of the switch, allowing the CIA to take over the switch and then do away with Snowden with impunity. By contrast the passive distributed key storage he likely has provides no active traffic that current surveillance can trace.
I'm thinking something like a python script which is scanning for particular words and phrases on google news, like "Snowden killed", or "Snowden captured"? That seems like something I could build easily -- would a kill switch indeed be something as simple as that?
The only problem is, that complicates the system with a critical point of failure.
What if Putin decides to cut the wifi at Moscow airport? Is that an 'apocalypse' situation or not?
Because people are smarter than computers.
In other words: If you know how to stop the distribution, wouldn't there be feasible ways to make you stop it?
" ‘Snowden won’t disclose more docs, I have thousands’ – Greenwald"
"Edward Snowden is unlikely to make new revelations since “he doesn’t want to end up in a cage like Bradley Manning”, said The Guardian journalist Glenn Greenwald, adding that he himself decides what to publish from the thousands of leaked documents.
...
"But Snowden’s case is actually a kind of reverse dead man’s switch, says John Prados, senior research fellow for the National Security Archive and author of several books on secret wars of the CIA. [...] “In the dead man switch, my positive control is necessary in order to prevent the eventuality [of an explosion],” Prados said. “In Snowden’s information strategy, he distributed sets of the information in such a fashion that if he is taken, then other people will move to release information. In other words, his positive control of the system is not required to make the eventuality happen. In fact, it’s his negative control that applies."
I'm really surprised it was implemented like that, I think using an actual, digital "dead man's switch" would have made more sense. Why not have 100 servers around the world running jobs to email out documents to 100 journalists at all times if an env variable isn't reset every few weeks? Then if he disappears or is killed, a few weeks later the jobs complete and email out the information?