Re:Federal tax collection drop 34% year over year
by jerf on Wednesday May 13, 2009 @12:41AM
(#606533)
"The problem is that there's a lower bound on what government can spend and still be effective."
True, but it would only be relevant if we were anywhere even remotely near that spending limit. I can cut about 75% out of the Federal budget and government will still be "effective". No Social Security, Medicaid, much smaller military, and a lot less subsidizing, but laws will still be passed, police services will be untouched, and all the truly basic functions of government will continue on.
I for one can't stomach a definition of "basic effective government" that includes things that didn't even exist 100 years ago. What we need from our government is law, order, basic public safety, defense from our neighbors, and little else. What we want is another story.
I'm not advocating this. I'm substantiating my point that we are nowhere near the true "lower bound". Which is good, actually. If you're implicitly claiming that we actually are near the lower bound, and I also add the observation that we may very well be mere months or weeks away from no longer being able to afford the government we have (that bond auction story is scary), then we're all in real trouble when the upper bound of the government's spending drops below the lower bound of the government's spending. I think a lot of people are about to re-learn the difference between "want" and "need".
True, but it would only be relevant if we were anywhere even remotely near that spending limit. I can cut about 75% out of the Federal budget and government will still be "effective". No Social Security, Medicaid, much smaller military, and a lot less subsidizing, but laws will still be passed, police services will be untouched, and all the truly basic functions of government will continue on.
I for one can't stomach a definition of "basic effective government" that includes things that didn't even exist 100 years ago. What we need from our government is law, order, basic public safety, defense from our neighbors, and little else. What we want is another story.
I'm not advocating this. I'm substantiating my point that we are nowhere near the true "lower bound". Which is good, actually. If you're implicitly claiming that we actually are near the lower bound, and I also add the observation that we may very well be mere months or weeks away from no longer being able to afford the government we have (that bond auction story is scary), then we're all in real trouble when the upper bound of the government's spending drops below the lower bound of the government's spending. I think a lot of people are about to re-learn the difference between "want" and "need".