Re:‘America has no functioning democracy at this moment’ – J...
by tptacek on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:54PM
(#6065279)
Because that's exactly the point I'm making? That we should be OK with anything the US does up to coups and HUAC?
Re:‘America has no functioning democracy at this moment’ – J...
by samstave on Thursday July 18, 2013 @02:09PM
(#6065370)
Based on the words you used and the order in which you wrote them, that is how I took your comment. If that was not your point, then maybe I am being obtuse and over reactionary? But when you posted what you did, closing with a criticism of Carter being a "coot" -- you certainly appeared to me to be making the point: "The USG has always been thinly veiled totalitarianism disguised as democracy, and as such one should certainly not be surprised, nor objectionable to the current version of the same-old-same-old"
These actions, now and in hte past, are unacceptable. Period - under any government in any era.
We should not raise a peep against the NSA, afterall, as you state - its lunacy to think we are not better off now than we were in the past. Further, who should complain about a government agency given supposed "legal" freedom to do absolutely anything it wants with any and all human communications across the globe!
All this in a time where the reach of the US military is literally global and can kill any stated enemy combatant at the push of a button. If you're innocent little snowflake is killed in that attack, gee, sorry about that, we must have had bad intel!
So, in the end, while your comment that things were also bad "back in the day" -- this in absolutely no way should preclude anyone from complaining about the excessive, tyrannical over-reach of the NSA and the USG. So to that end, I say fuck your argument, completely because its a cop-out to the fact that the world, and the NSA in particular, have gone to far.
I want my privacy, my freedom and my safety (even from the arm of the USG) and all at the same damn time!