News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by rayiner on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:27PM (#6064670)
> The American citizenry tends to be OK with this kind of thing as long as it happens far away from us.

It's not that it's far away from us, it's that it happens to others. In this case, to the family of a terrorist that, while born in the U.S., spent a decade waging war against the U.S. on behalf of Al Qaeda while eluding every attempt to bring him to justice.

The U.S. reserves the right to have different rules for us versus others like every other people in the history of the world.

Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by stenl on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:39PM (#6064742)
So the rule is, the president can kill the family members of whomever he considers a terrorist? As in, not the terrorist himself, but his son? Where does that power end? Three degrees of separation, like NSA spying?

Sorry, but this is the sign of a seriously f*ed up nation.

Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by rayiner on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:05PM (#6064936)
As far as I can tell, the attack that killed his son a month later was aimed at killing other members of Al Qaeda: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/16/world/middleeast/yemeni-se... ("Airstrikes, believed to have been carried out by American drones, killed at least nine people in southern Yemen on Friday, including a senior official of the regional branch of Al Qaeda and an American, the 17-year-old son of a Qaeda official killed by the United States last month, according to the government and local reports on Saturday.").
Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by arh68 on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:29PM (#6064685)
Do you have a good test for 'us' vs 'others' other than citizenship? What should it be based on? What should we call 'us', and what should we call the 'others'? 'Citizens' & 'Foreigners' seems to be pretty good already.
Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by rayiner on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:34PM (#6064720)
I think citizenship is a good general rule, but like every rule it has corner cases. But citizenship guarantees you due process, not a trial regardless of the circumstances. At some point, it becomes impractical to provide a trial (e.g. consider a police man killing a suspect because he presents an imminent deadly threat).

We did give civilian trials to terrorists like John Walker Lindh and Jose Padilla who were American citizens in our custody. But Al Awalki evaded our attempts to give him judicial process for a decade. Does citizenship mean that you can't be touched as long as authorities can't bring you in alive?

Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by arh68 on Thursday July 18, 2013 @02:21PM (#6065438)
I think it's a false dichotomy to either use kid gloves for citizens or secret hit lists. To compare with the recent Snowden extradition attempt, charges were filed and authorities were notified. Why should Snowden & Anwar be apprehended any differently? To quote Wikipedia,

> Yemeni authorities offered guarantees they would not turn al-Awlaki over to the U.S. or let him be questioned.

This demands explanation from the State Dept why they didn't pressure Yemen like they recently did to countries offering relief to Snowden. US-Yemen relations cannot be evinced in an Internet comment, but it appears to me the US was quick to pull the trigger when other options were not fully exercised. The least they could have done was charge him, right?

Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by rayiner on Thursday July 18, 2013 @02:35PM (#6065540)
Because unlike the places where Snowden was, Yemen is a barely functioning nation state? He was on the Yemeni government's most wanted list but was hiding in regions the government had little control over.

The places where we're conducting drone strikes are beyond the wild west. My dad was in Yemen when the Yemeni civil war broke out, and his hotel in the capital was shelled when fighting reached the city (he was ultimately evacuated with the other U.S. citizens by the U.S. military). The civil war is long over but the government has never been anything other than precarious, and the tribes have tremendous political power. One of the things Al Awlaki did was offer the protection of his powerful tribe to Al Qaeda officials against the Yemeni government.

Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by randomknowledge on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:37PM (#6064733)
from the article: "The government repeatedly made accusations of terrorism against Anwar — who was also an American citizen — but never charged him with a crime. No court ever reviewed the government’s claims nor was any evidence of criminal wrongdoing ever presented to a court. "
Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by jmduke on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:47PM (#6064793)
No court ever reviewed the government’s claims nor was any evidence of criminal wrongdoing ever presented to a court.

The Yemeni government began trying him in absentia in November 2010, for plotting to kill foreigners and being a member of al-Qaeda. A Yemeni judge ordered that he be captured "dead or alive.

This is a very well-written piece, but the (clearly intelligent and well-spoken) author's characterization of his son makes me suspicious of the rest of the content.