Re:Obama wins back the right to indefinitely detain under NDAA
by grey-area on Thursday July 18, 2013 @07:31AM
(#6062868)
This is why terrorists, and suspected terrorists, need to be given exactly the same rights under the law as everyone else.
Re:Obama wins back the right to indefinitely detain under NDAA
by DanBC on Thursday July 18, 2013 @07:34AM
(#6062881)
Suspected terrorist talking to a lawyer before facing trial and being found not guilty / guilty is much worse TV[1] than Kiefer Sutherland torturing the terrorist to prevent the bomb killing lots of people.
[1] Some people think it's worse.
Re:Obama wins back the right to indefinitely detain under NDAA
by jbooth on Thursday July 18, 2013 @07:44AM
(#6062910)
The concepts aren't even opposed.
If, hypothetically, there actually is a ticking bomb somewhere (this has never happened that we know of), just break the law. You'll sort it out later. If you were right, there will be a pardon, if you were wrong, you'll go to jail.
In every other possible scenario, the law should protect rights of the accused.
Re:Obama wins back the right to indefinitely detain under NDAA
by canvia on Thursday July 18, 2013 @09:15AM
(#6063369)
There was a pretty good movie that made you think about that type of situation, "Unthinkable" http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0914863/
It's like the question in Swordfish, would you be willing to sacrifice the life of an innocent to save 10,000 people's lives? How about 2 innocents? What about 500?
Once you start to consider making those kinds of trade offs it's a very slippery slope. It seems to me the only correct answer is 0. There is no acceptable trade off to try and counter irrational actions.
I'm not sure whether this applies much in the kinds of situations where this in particular is used, but in this country people have rights such as silence that can be circumvented because suspected terrorists are treated differently and have fewer rights - those who don't cooperate will continue to be treated as terrorists.