When SmartFlix's revenues fell, we cut our budget in a lot of places ... and some of those hurt.
Here in MA, the mass transit agency (MBTA) can't even push through a one year salary FREEZE.
You sure get a different view of the world when you only collect as much money as your customers choose to give you, as opposed to being able to take all you want...
If a business has to cut jobs, that affects that business and those people, and if the business dies as a result of that revenue shortage or from those job cuts, it's pretty localized.
Can you really do the same thing with police officers or the fire department? Or with the DMV? Or social services, which people need more of during a recession, not less? Do you really just cut the fire department in half? Or expect everyone therein to take a 50% pay cut? So you cut salaries or freeze them, you cut back staffing as much as you reasonably can, etc. But there's a real lower bound on how much you can cut, and you can't just say, "Well, we have 50% less money this quarter, so we'll just have 50% as many policy officers."
I'm not saying I have any answers to those questions, or that government budgeting practices are ideal or rational (I live in CA, so if you want to talk about messed up budgeting . . .). But you also have to realize that it's a very, very different problem space, and the government fundamentally isn't in a position to absorb sudden, huge drops in revenue the way a business or individual has to just by cutting back on spending.
True, but it would only be relevant if we were anywhere even remotely near that spending limit. I can cut about 75% out of the Federal budget and government will still be "effective". No Social Security, Medicaid, much smaller military, and a lot less subsidizing, but laws will still be passed, police services will be untouched, and all the truly basic functions of government will continue on.
I for one can't stomach a definition of "basic effective government" that includes things that didn't even exist 100 years ago. What we need from our government is law, order, basic public safety, defense from our neighbors, and little else. What we want is another story.
I'm not advocating this. I'm substantiating my point that we are nowhere near the true "lower bound". Which is good, actually. If you're implicitly claiming that we actually are near the lower bound, and I also add the observation that we may very well be mere months or weeks away from no longer being able to afford the government we have (that bond auction story is scary), then we're all in real trouble when the upper bound of the government's spending drops below the lower bound of the government's spending. I think a lot of people are about to re-learn the difference between "want" and "need".
It sounds like a joke, but it's real. You might thing they could take some of the money from the renewal fee, but nope.