News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by tzs on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:45PM (#6061484)
That's true as long as people need jobs in order to have a decent life. Eventually, the productivity gains from technology should produce enough gain to allow for a guaranteed basic income [1] sufficient to allow displaced workers to effectively retire if they wish. You'll only need to find a job if you want more than the GBI can provide.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_guarantee

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by jiggy2011 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:58PM (#6061530)
Question is, at what point do you implement that? Any politician who stands up and says "We have given up on lowering unemployment, time to pay everyone to stay at home" is not going to be popular until the problem is of such a magnitude that you cannot ignore it.

Even in such a situation, what incentive besides purely humanitarian does an individual with a job have to sacrifice income for those who do not?

Currently you can justify subsidising a non productive person in the hopes that they will be productive later. What happens if that is highly unlikely and instead they devote their time to breeding more people who will also likely become unproductive and require subsidy?

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by gambogi on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @11:22PM (#6061603)
We know that intrinisically motivated people will aspire to do, even if there isn't a need for them too. If we provide for both the intrinsic and extrinsic, we effectively cover 100% of motivated individuals. By making it easy for those with passion to act on it we do all of society a favor. As for the non-productive members of society, it's not a huge issue because they don't need to be productive to live. This means that your right to live is unconditional. Excuse my corniness, but after all, why should there be conditions on your right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness?
Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by jiggy2011 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @11:37PM (#6061646)
What about the jobs that still need doing but people are not generally highly intrinsically motivated to do relative to other things they could be doing if they had free choice?

For example if you gave software developers a bunch of cash and told them to work on whatever they wanted, how many would go and build video games or invent esoteric programming languages (fun but not important) vs how many would want to build (or worse maintain) a system for the administration of taxes (less fun but very important). Hell, how many would even develop software at all vs just take up some other activity of even less value.

Therefor the best way to motivate these people is to extrinsic motivate them with money. However what happens if most of that money is taken as taxation and spent on people who sit around and do whatever they want all day? Do they still have the same incentive to do the boring but necessary jobs?

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by tzs on Thursday July 18, 2013 @07:40AM (#6062895)
> What about the jobs that still need doing but people are not generally highly intrinsically motivated to do relative to other things they could be doing if they had free choice?

There will be luxuries some people want that are beyond the reach of those who live just on the guaranteed basic income. Those people will do the jobs that have not yet been replaced by technology to earn the extra money they need.

For instance, some people might want more living space. Some might want fancier cars than those people on the GBI can afford. Some might fancy a boat. Some might want a high end home entertainment system. Some might like expensive food and drink.

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by jiggy2011 on Thursday July 18, 2013 @08:44AM (#6063181)
If you want to earn money to have these luxuries , why pay to those who don't give you anything in return (nor have the potential to)?
Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by gambogi on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:25AM (#6061771)
Well, first of all, I'm not arguing for equal pay for everyone, I'm in favor of a guarenteed minimum income. Secondly, money doesn't work as a motivator for non menial tasks.[1] And you know, a task that seems boring and uninteresting to you might not for someone else. As for how many of us would even develop software at all, I need only point to the open source community. Extrinsic notivation has its place, but it is no substitute for that internal drive.

[1] http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_pink_on_motivation.html

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by jiggy2011 on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:02AM (#6061862)
I don't think it's true that money doesn't work as a motivation for non-menial tasks, if that were the case then there would be no incentive for tech companies to offer developers anything over a sustenance wage since they would show up to work for free.

Open source software is an interesting example, but I think it mostly supports my case.

If you look at the projects out there, you can divide them into roughly 3 camps.

1) Projects that have a lot of paid developers working for companies or organisations that pay wages to their developers. So stuff like Android , V8 and Ubuntu would fall into this camp.

2) Projects that people were not necessarily paid to develop , but were developed mostly as a biproduct of something that they were or as a way to do that thing more effectively. "Scratch an itch" software effectively. I guess something like RoR would fall into this category.

3) Pure passion projects that were developed for fun. This is the only group that is purely intrinsically motivated.

The thing with projects that fall into camp #3 is that they tend to be stuff that the developer themselves found useful or interesting rather than something that necessarily serves society at large, though the two may sometimes intersect there is no guarantee.

If you don't make peoples incomes at least somewhat dependant upon the software they develop you will see far more camp #3 projects than camps #1 or #2.

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by fnordfnordfnord on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @11:11PM (#6061565)
tzs is right though, at some point we will automate most of the labor/service jobs away. We either need to dispense with the whole protestant-work-ethic sing-for-your-supper crap, or make damn sure that we have enough stuff to do, and that people have the resources (access to education) they need to do new jobs.

" time to pay everyone to stay at home"

There are various levels of "paying everyone to stay at home" There is moving to a part-time employment model. There are also possibilities for interesting good things to happen to the labor market once everyone is not trapped in "must always work" mode.

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by jiggy2011 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @11:23PM (#6061608)
Could you move to a part time employment model without legally imposing a maximum on the number of hours each person can work?

I know I would certainly not willingly give up half my hours and income and have to put all of my work in a state where someone else can take over every few days.

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:26AM (#6061775)
>Could you move to a part time employment model without legally imposing a maximum on the number of hours each person can work?

I think the taxman's bludgeon would be the weapon of choice here.

>I know I would certainly not willingly give up half my hours and income and have to put all of my work in a state where someone else can take over every few days.

What do you propose as an alternative? A worker-class and a loafer-class? Prisons? Eugenics? Population control isn't very warm and fuzzy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5iFESMAU58&list=PL381A1925D...

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by jiggy2011 on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:11AM (#6061884)
Would you tax people based on the number of hours they worked? What about people who are not paid hourly, which would increase drastically unless you outlawed it.

Then you have to define what counts as "work", does reading HN count towards your daily allowance since it is tangentially related to your work? What about reading documentation? Or is it only the hours you are typing code into an editor?

All options seem undesirable when you take them to their logical conclusions.

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:53AM (#6061994)
>Would you tax people based on the number of hours they worked?

Not me man, I have a job. I just said taxes because that seems like the favorite/most humane weapon of gov't with which to influence people.

>All options seem undesirable when you take them to their logical conclusions.

Such is the case for doing nothing as well, I believe.

Re:How Technology Is Destroying Jobs by sneak on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @11:21PM (#6061598)
You're not from around here, are you?