News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yahoo Mail is not catching up anymore by gcb0 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:36PM (#6061222)
undo send is dumb and the worst name/implementation.

i'd either add a dialog (with default selected button being Cancel) or replace the Send button with a Preview button, which would show the message the same way you read a message, and there you would have the Send button.

Re:Yahoo Mail is not catching up anymore by nnethercote on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:40PM (#6061464)
Undo send is great. It lets you undo the one time in a hundred that you make a mistake. Your solution would require that everybody click through an additional dialog on every single email sent.

Letting people recover from uncommon mistakes is better than ham-fisted and annoying mechanisms that attempt to prevent the mistake.

Re:Yahoo Mail is not catching up anymore by gcb0 on Thursday July 18, 2013 @03:25AM (#6062275)
"undo" email does nothing else than create a false sense of security.

It probably works for the impatient that is hitting ctrl+enter (or whatever shortcut) too soon by muscle memory. but then it should be called delayed send to not give a false mental model to the user.

the current model is preventing the real mistakes for probably 1/10 of the cases it's needed. and enticing less care and probably bumping the rate in the end.

Re:Yahoo Mail is not catching up anymore by fluffyllemon on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:55PM (#6061523)
Neither the dialog nor the preview solves the problem that an undo button solves.

If a dialog or preview comes up for every message you send, you just develop a new habit for sending mail (press the send button, then press the send button again on the dialog / preview). If anything, it just creates more of a hassle for the user.

The undo button is for that 'Oh crap!' moment, when your auto-pilot lead you astray.