News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies? by aa0 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:13PM (#6061123)
The technical reason is that Netflix is "cutting corners" for cash. I'm sure someone in the media licensing industry can elaborate on the true price of what you crave.
Re:Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies? by pfraze on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:20PM (#6061157)
> what you crave

Electrolytes?

But in all seriousness: are there any numbers we can refer to for the economics of this? It sounds like it could be similar to the issues around royalties paid by music streaming services.

Re:Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies? by jfb on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:47PM (#6061492)
What, you're a plant?

I was going to say that this looks a lot more like expedience ("hey, we've got this version of Some Terrible Straight To DVD Movie stored in 4:3 SD 8Mb/s MPEG-2, let's send 'em that!") but both examples are a) relatively high profile and b) not 4:3 pan/scan crops. They look to be cropped to 16:9, which is weird, and makes me think that it's happening inside Netflix's video pipeline.

Hmm.

Re:Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies? by 616c on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:26AM (#6061921)
Watch and your questions shall be answered.

http://movies.netflix.com/WiMovie/Idiocracy/70028899?locale=...

Re:Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies? by Osiris on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:44PM (#6061483)
How are they cutting corners? The wider aspect ratio would actually use fewer pixel data since about 80-240 vertical pixels (assuming 1920 width) would not be encoded. If anything, those versions would result is slightly lower bandwidth charges than the 16:9 versions.
Re:Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies? by jfb on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:49PM (#6061502)
That's not how it works. They'll set a bandwidth target and regardless of the number of macroblocks going in, their encoder will attempt to hit that target; having less picture data per frame is largely immaterial, at least at the sizes being discussed.
Re:Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies? by Terretta on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:59PM (#6061533)
Parent is right, it's how it "should" work. Encode for a quality target not a bandwidth target, but with a bandwidth cap (of sorts, generally a virtual buffer average bitrate target to simulate refilling bit buffer at targeted line speeds when depleted by high motion or latency).

Source: Built and operate a commercial transcoding cloud for studios.

EDIT: Added "should". As jfb noted elsewhere in this thread, often poorly encoded content is shoved down aggregators throats by content owners or third parties in the workflow.

Re:Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies? by jfb on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @11:02PM (#6061544)
I built the iTunes Store's video ingestion system. We may have crossed paths IRL.
Re:Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies? by Terretta on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @11:36PM (#6061642)
Small world. Could you drop me a note to my handle at gmail so I can reply?
Re:Why Is Netflix Secretly Cropping Movies? by surge on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:27PM (#6064668)
I think a Netflix tech sounded off on reddit about this and said that it's not up to them, its up to the distributor they license the content from. They request the 16:9 format, but in the end they have to go with what the distributor gives them and they aren't allowed to alter it. This is a licensing thing, not Netflix interfering. As pointed out, Starz Play was the worse offender, which means Starz gave it to them preformatted. Possibly to make it so if it's pirated, it's not the full format version.

If you're such a cinephile, why watch it on Netflix anyway? Just go buy the Bluray and get the full resolution and director's cut. How many of you even cared before reading this article?